3 ms·
That's only true if they continue growing reliably after being deplatformed. There's no reason why that should necessarily be true. I feel like there a tendenc
by PhasmaFelis 7y ago
That's only true if they continue growing reliably after being deplatformed. There's no reason why that should necessarily be true.
I feel like there a tendency to believe that, since censorship is bad, censorship must also be completely ineffective, and we tell stories like "deplatforming is useless" to reinforce that. But I don't think that's a realistic approach. Censorship can and does work, in the right circumstances. Chinese millennials may know that something happened at Tiananmen Square in 1989, but they're fuzzy on the details and inclined to downplay it and keep quiet about it. That's censorship working as intended. Assuming your enemies are incompetent doesn't accomplish anything but a false sense of security.
- averros 7y agoChinese millenials not wishing to talk about Tiananmen Sq is not "censorship working". It's intimidation working. You talk about wrong thing, it gets into your file. You say too much and then you discover you're passed for promotion at work or denied admission to school of your choice, or whatever. I know precisely how it works because I lived in a country which did exactly that. Nothing official, but everyone knew. And it's coming to US. Courtesy of tech imbeciles who think that collecting detailed dossiers on everyone is a good idea.