6 ms·
> 6) Anyone who doesn’t do this will be fired. So I've never worked at a company over 150 people. Is this... a normal thing for an email? Maybe I'm just one of
by Waterluvian 7y ago
> 6) Anyone who doesn’t do this will be fired.
So I've never worked at a company over 150 people. Is this... a normal thing for an email? Maybe I'm just one of those softies but an email with that line would throw me off my day and cause a serious hit to my morale and confidence of working there.
- inimino 7y agoThis is Yegge's over-the-top style of humor, none of these are actual quotes from the email.
- wayoutthere 7y agoTo be fair, "do this or you're fired" is just assumed of every request at Amazon, because they follow through on it often.
- jrd259 7y agoIn my five-year experience at Amazon that has never been true.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- jeffbarr 7y agoI strongly believe that Steve was exaggerating for effect here. In my 17 years at Amazon I have never seen or heard of a threat of this nature. The overall intent of the email was to tell teams to decouple, decentralize, and to own their own destinies.
- Waterluvian 7y agoThanks for the reality check. Phew.
- michaelcampbell 7y agoYes, IIRC in Steve's original blog post he points out that that particular point was not in Bezos' email and notes he put it in there for dramatic effect.
- maxlybbert 7y agoWhat I remember from Yegge’s blog post was that the “have a nice day” bullet point was a joke; Bezos doesn’t spend much time worrying about how each employee’s day is going.
- solarengineer 7y agoAn ex Netflix person, who has since moved to Amazon, spoke at a client place three weeks ago. He casually mentioned things such as "we forgive the first time, and we fire the second time". From how he spoke, we felt that this may be the norm in Silicon Valley and related places. I have much respect for what he has achieved, so I didn't interrupt to question such a fear-inducing mindset.
- blub 7y agoI remember reading that their head of HR was very supportive of this firing policy and she was herself fired: https://www.fastcompany.com/3056662/she-created-netflixs-culture-and-it-ultimately-got-her-fired https://www.fastcompany.com/3056662/she-created-netflixs-cul... :)
- drclau 7y agoThanks for sharing this article. The part about McCord firing an employee is sad and funny at the same time. To begin with, it looks like a page from Vonnegut’s Player Piano: “McCord mentioned letting go a product testing employee who “was great,” but eventually lost her job to automation.” It isn’t mentioned if the employee contributed to the automation that eventually replaced her, but it may as well be so. Nevertheless, her depiction of the conversation is a rare mix of sad and funny: “So I called her up. I’m like, what part of this is a surprise? … And she goes, yeah, but, you know, I’ve worked really hard; this is really unfair. I’m like, and you’re crying? She’s like, yeah. I’m like, will you dry your tears and hold your head up and go be from Netflix? You’re the–why do you think you’re the last one here–’cause you’re the best. You’re incredibly good at what you do. We just don’t need you to do it anymore.”
- airstrike 7y agoOne man's "fear-inducing" is another man's "results-driven"
- everdrive 7y agoWith such important services as streaming Seinfeld, it's easy to see why such a scorched earth policy is necessary.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- thrwaway647 7y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong, but it seems the actual email is neither quoted directly nor linked in the post.
- Jach 7y agoNot in such language, but it's absolutely the case that large companies can have emails come from the very top that include language like "subject to disciplinary action and possible termination" for failing to do some required thing. Sometimes it's phrased as "corrective action up to and including termination." It's normal in that this is something that shouldn't throw one for a loop (and in my experience the calls to action have more to do with regulation compliance than any how-to-do-your-job mandate) but it's not very frequent. Such language is usually limited to appearing in an employee handbook or conduct guide that everyone is supposed to have read and agreed to which spells out repercussions for behavior against such or other misconduct.
- rodolphoarruda 7y agoIt is quite usual in global consulting organizations. The format is always like this: "X has happened, is happening or may happen. X is bad. Any Y or Z actions identified in our workforce related to X will be subject of termination of employment."
- maxlybbert 7y agoVery few managers in large companies can throw around threats like that, and the ones who can realize it just makes them look unhinged like the Queen of Hearts in “Alice in Wonderland.” Incidentally, a couple of years ago, I was a contractor for Amazon for a very short time. One thing that stood out was that customers would email Bezos directly, or problems would bubble up to him in some other way, and he would respond by forwarding the email to an appropriate email list. Bezos’s email would be just a question mark, but he always got a fast and complete reply. Once people knew he was paying attention, they would do anything to resolve the problem. He didn’t need to formulate an actual question, or even a general “what’s this about?”, just a literal question mark would do the trick.
- babesh 7y agoThat is pretty normal, both in the CEO or founder just asking or having to ask a question and the quickness and lengths that people go to to address it. People don’t actually get credit for addressing the issue. People just get dinged for not addressing the issue quickly. It is actually a red flag if a CEO or founder doesn’t behave this way since it means that they aren’t showing care and attention or that they are operating at the wrong level.
- aglavine 7y agoIt is corporate language for "this is our first and most important priority and should be noticed and followed by anyone"
- chmod775 7y agoYour parent comment kind of ripped that one out of context by omitting the following statement that is supposed to contrast with the preceding statement in a humorous way (IMHO). 6) Anyone who doesn’t do this will be fired. 7) Thank you; have a nice day! This makes it sound like hyperbole instead, or a quip used to essentially communicate "It's very high priority".
- Infernal 7y agoI know of one CIO (between 10k and 1k employees) who operates by tell/train/terminate. Tell the staff what to do, if they can’t then train them, if they’ve been trained and can’t/won’t then terminate them.
- invisiblerobot 7y agoIsnt that competence?
- Infernal 7y agoMy intention wasn’t to judge the position, just pass along the data point.
- BenoitEssiambre 7y agoElon Musk did this fairly recently at Tesla: "There are two schools of thought about how information should flow within companies. By far the most common way is chain of command, which means that you always flow communication through your manager. The problem with this approach is that, while it serves to enhance the power of the manager, it fails to serve the company. Instead of a problem getting solved quickly, where a person in one dept talks to a person in another dept and makes the right thing happen, people are forced to talk to their manager who talks to their manager who talks to the manager in the other dept who talks to someone on his team. Then the info has to flow back the other way again. This is incredibly dumb. Any manager who allows this to happen, let alone encourages it, will soon find themselves working at another company. No kidding."
- seph-reed 7y agoHeh. Threatening the managers. I love it.
- kokey 7y agoInformation doesn't have to flow through managers specifically and it certainly doesn't have to flow up the management chain and down again, but there ideally should be preferred funnels for the communication and breaking out of it should be an exception, or pre arranged, and not the norm. Otherwise you'll have, say, a particularly useful person on a team see his time filled with requests coming from a lot of different directions and he then has to also manage the priorities and communication around this too, and then he becomes a bottleneck for the entire organisation.
- BenoitEssiambre 7y agoIf you have smart employees respectful of other's time it shouldn't be a problem. I would tend to agree with Musk on this one. Processes are often put in place to counteract poor hiring. If you need inefficiency raising processes to defend your business from your own employees, maybe you don't have the right employees.
- 7y ago
- equalunique 7y agoI wish emails like this were sent out in the places I've worked. Been surrounded by people with no initiative to do what's required, dragging everyone else down.
- Cpoll 7y agoI think the context matters. In this case, 'not doing this' doesn't mean making a mistake, it means ignoring a company-wide imperative, being insubordinate, hubristic, etc. I acknowledge that it's probably a joke anyway.
- astura 7y agoI've worked at ~250 person company, a multinational conglomerate you've definitely heard of, and everything in between. No, that sort of overly forceful yet flippant language it's not normal.
- syncsynchalt 7y agoI've worked at several large companies via acquisition. Yegge has punched things up a little, but I can translate #6 into what I believe was the original text: "This represents the new direction for {company}, and anyone who does not wish to align with this new direction should pursue other opportunities". The day-to-day employee at a large company becomes numb to executive emails, as 90% of the time they will be countermanded a month later. A sentence like the above is inserted to wake people up and indicate "no, seriously, this means you".