5 ms·
Early-career setback and future career impact
- jl2718 7y agoOr it’s just a filter for perseverance.
- salmonellaeater 7y agoThe paper tests this hypothesis and finds that there's probably a causal effect: "...these results demonstrate that the screening effect may have played a role, but it appears insufficient to entirely account for the observed difference between near misses and narrow wins."
- inlined 7y ago+1. The dual populations of dropouts and higher performers smells like survivorship bias.
- mbreese 7y agoOr researchers who had near misses are at institutions (or moved to institutions) that have sufficient internal resources to get early career researchers bridge funding to keep them productive during their funding lull. I think there are so many ways for people to get lost in the current finding environment, that would be extremely difficult to be able to make any findings to how people performed. The main exception I see is the attrition rate. This is the measure they reported that I have the most confidence in. As was said elsewhere, everything else just smalls of a survivorship bias.
- craftinator 7y agoI, too, love to nuture scientists. Yum!
- lioeters 7y ago> ..Early-career setback appears to cause a performance improvement among those who persevere. > ..These findings are consistent with the concept that “what doesn’t kill me makes me stronger,” which may have broad implications for identifying, training and nurturing junior scientists. Good to hear, as someone who (is not a scientist but) has had a fair share of early-career setbacks, from external causes, bad luck, as well as self-inflicted in youthful ignorance. :) At least from an anecdotal retrospective of my current blessed situation, surviving and overcoming these setbacks have indeed made me more resilient and persistently motivated.
- jar_cup_bowl 7y agoAnecdote: My company has recently passed on a few early career candidates who pretty clearly hadn't been mentored. We have a take-home assignment as part of our interview process and they were able to get a working solution, but missed on design patterns that would make their code more maintainable and extensible, things that are usually learned from code-reviews by people who have had the experience of working with bad code. This was more common in candidates who came to us from the tech departments of non-tech focused companies. We lamented not being able to hire otherwise smart and personable candidates, but at the end of the day we only had headcount for 1 employee and we went with a different smart and personable candidate who had better early career opportunities.
- ticmasta 7y agoSo you allocated scarce resources to the best available candidate you could find? ...or there's something I'm missing...?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- whatshisface 7y agoThe parent is pointing out that they continued the pattern of the setback by denying a candidate the opportunity to learn the skills whose absence resulted in their denial. It's a catch-22 which for them started with their first job out of school.
- gridlockd 7y agoReading it, there's at least a 50% chance that learning at this company would've made them worse developers that focus too much on stuff that doesn't really matter.
- jschwartzi 7y ago> Anecdote: My company has recently passed on a few early career candidates who pretty clearly hadn't been mentored. Either that or the candidates you passed on simply didn't want to spend several hours making enterprise-grade software for a take-home test that they're not getting paid for.
- pazimzadeh 7y agoFigure 2 and 3 legends don't start at zero. What in the world?
- mch82 7y agoI’m sure I’ll feel silly when someone finds them, but are the concepts of “narrow win” and “near miss” defines in the context of this paper? Is “career setback” defined?
- laser 7y agoIn the abstract “Here we examine junior scientists applying for National Institutes of Health R01 grants. By focusing on proposals fell just below and just above the funding threshold, we compare near-miss with narrow-win applicants” In other words, scientists who just barely missed funding “near miss” versus scientists who just barely were over the threshold to receive it “narrow win”.
- mch82 7y agoThank you
- verelo 7y agoFunny personal story: In 2008 i applied for an IT role at News Corp in Sydney Australia, i didn’t get the job. In 2015 they (one of their subsidiary companies) acquired the company that i founded with two other partners. A much better outcome.
- jammygit 7y agoI like the conclusion but I have to dispute it: there is a snowball effect for motivated (and resilient) people. Maybe this shows that most people are not motivated and need a kick in the pants, but if you are clever and you get ahead, you can use that to get more ahead (otherwise you were not really ahead at all)
- domnomnom 7y agoCode and data is here: https://yang-wangnu.github.io/setback/ https://yang-wangnu.github.io/setback/
- throwawayy98121 7y agoCome work at Amazon. If you can survive at Amazon, you can literally work anywhere afterwards (assuming they hire you and you’re not an asshole).
- kshacker 7y agoAnother funny personal story: since someone shared one. Started developing a taste for studying and computers at age 12-13. Did not hit a stumbling block till 40. Oh yes there were bad times but it was always one valley to another peak and at 40 the tide turned. I would not say it was the Midas touch, it was not, there were others way more successful but I look at my growth based on my aspirations and capabilities. And then the fall. Took 5 years to realize the fubar situation and then maybe 6 years of perseverance with a course correction ;) Even before the article I realized that the lack of failures in early days probably hurt me in the long run. Once again, this is a very simplified version. Even I could find flaws in my presentation of details if I needed to.