5 ms·
The very notion that people want free government and self-determination is a bad thing is why you're being downvoted on an American forum. There is not a lot of
by unethical_ban 7y ago
The very notion that people want free government and self-determination is a bad thing is why you're being downvoted on an American forum. There is not a lot of support for oppressive governments that commit genocide against religious minorities and put people in prison for political dissidence.
You may be playing devil's advocate for the "party" but it comes too close to sounding like you're defending them.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe irony is of course to downvote to hell any dissenting comment in a debate about democratic values and censorship in China...
- unethical_ban 7y agoThere is no irony. I am not calling the authorities to have you and your family beaten and arrested.
- tempguy9999 7y agoA dissenting comment that is wrong is a bad comment and deserves downvoting for being wrong. I'm not saying it is wrong, but expecting that democracy means all opinions are valid is a very basic misunderstanding. Very basic.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoAt the very least it does mean not suppressing opinions that you consider 'wrong'. This is not a discussion on a technical or scientific topic. This is not black and white. In fact, and since someone mentioned the American nationality of HN, the lack of subtlety and the need to see everything in black and white, right or wrong, is a common 'criticisim', so to speak, about Americans.
- tempguy9999 7y ago> At the very least it does mean not suppressing opinions that you consider 'wrong'. true! > This is not black and white. Potentially true, but I feel you're fogging the issue (something that happens a surprising amount of time in these discussions involving china). I distinguished between dissenting comments and bad comments. While that's not utterly B/W it's actually pretty clear. > In fact, and since someone mentioned the American nationality of HN, the lack of subtlety and the need to see everything in black and white, right or wrong, is a common 'criticisim', so to speak, about Americans. Ah good old racism! And it is racism BTW. Americans are crude, stupid and gunslinging morons. Well, I've met a very few like that, very few indeed. Can I make some obnoxious and unfair generalisations about the chinese? You're OK with that I take it? I'm a brit BTW.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe downside of freedom of speech is what one has to read, sometimes..
- tempguy9999 7y agoThat insinuation that I'm uneducated addresses none of my points. So how about replying to the given issues.
- rumanator 7y ago> The irony is of course to downvote to hell any dissenting comment in a debate about democratic values and censorship in China... Please don't confuse PR posts conducted by China's 50 cent army lauding absurdities such as the virtues of a totalitarian regime as "dissenting comment".
- mytailorisrich 7y agoPlease stop assuming that any comment that does not share your opinion on China is fake.
- sho 7y ago> There is not a lot of support for oppressive governments that commit genocide against religious minorities and put people in prison for political dissidence. That's funny, I thought Saudi Arabia was America's close ally. Yuuuge deals on military hardware, great against defenseless Yemeni citizens. Free bone saw with every 10th missile!