3 ms·
An interesting experience from this history is showing how parasites jump in zero seconds to a handful of other species when its main host is unavoidable. We w
by pvaldes 7y ago
An interesting experience from this history is showing how parasites jump in zero seconds to a handful of other species when its main host is unavoidable.
We were repeatedly guaranteed for years than Guinea worms were exclusive from humans. Thus wiping it would not affect any other species, and could be protected only if some humans would agree to suffer the parasite in their bodies, that is a gross price. Now we know that this was incorrect. Plain false, and nobody see it.
The species is linked with other mammals, could be saved from extinction and is not different to a hundred thousand species of other parasites in the planet.
To decide to wipe an animal just because is ugly and unsentient is a deeply wrong path and a pandora box. Treating the drinking water would suffice to prevent most cases in human patients.
A similar problem could easily happen if we mess with mosquitoes without a full, extensive, complete, knowledge of what we are doing and asuming the consequences of it.
- mantap 7y agoI find this incomprehensible. It's a disease. What does it matter if it is bacteria, eukaryote or virus? Medicine involves killing things that interfere with us and hopefully eradicating them completely. The whole "mosquito extinction" fears are really overblown. Nobody is proposing to eradicate all species of mosquito - only the ones that carry malaria. And the normal system of eradication (removing standing water) is much more invasive than the proposed method of genetic engineering.
- pvaldes 7y agoNot, is not a disease, is an animal. An animal that can cause a non lethal and treatable disease in part of its life cicle, and is linked with copepods, frogs and fishes, dogs, baboons and humans. There is a simple solution in two steps to avoid being infected with guinea worms: 1) don't drink copepods. Provide african people living in the same distribution area as this animal with a modern system of water purification; or teach them to boil the water before drink it, so they will not eat alive water fleas that carry the larvae. Simply filter the water trough a cloth before drinking would be enough to protect you from this parasite (but will not protect against other problems so boiled water technique is much more safe). If not, use chemicals to treat drinking water. and 2) people infected by the parasite should avoid to bath in drinking water or put their wounded feet in drinking water. Life cycle stopped and end of the problem in the same year with the magic of parasitology Why we sould not run to extinct entire species? We don't know where hides the next cure for cancer, the next cool matherial for engineery or the next modern generations of painkillers. Parasites had helped in the past with some of our problems and could hold the key to a treasure of solutions to our present and future problems. Even if not, to randomly remove pieces of a machine could lead to unexpected consequences. This animal is the result of million years of evolution and when is gone, is gone forever. If we find in the future that some of those consequences are undesirable, the machine is beyond repair.
- snagglegaggle 7y agoIt's as easy as those two steps, but in most of Africa those two steps are not easy. Read the article: for the people in Africa affected by the worm the disease is so debilitating they are unable to grow food or continue their education. This parasite ruins lives. >Why we sould not run to extinct entire species? We don't know where hides the next cure for cancer, This is like trying to argue against abortion because any given baby could be the next Einstein. Sure, but any given baby could also be the next Hitler... and both statements aren't even wrong (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_even_wrong). Whatever ill effects of the guinea worm's extinction can be overcome. If they can't, we were all probably going to die anyway.
- pvaldes 7y agoI'm reasonably sure that we will not find a tiny hitler inside the packets of 6 guinea worms, but if is really there, we could choose just not follow it The "not even wrong" argument is incorrectly applied here. We are not talking of filosophy, this is biology so the idea that parasites can be useful is perfectly falsifiable. We can just do more research and find if something in this animal is useful (nothing prevent us to do this because, well... is not extinct). We have many examples of parasites doing useful things before and the "99%" of species are still really poorly known, so that wouldn't be an impossible scenery. Here is another humble and useless roundworm that fortunately nobody decided to extinct before 1960's: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caenorhabditis_elegans https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Caenorhabditis_elegans From living in mudville streets to became a space survivor and genetic rockstar. Not bad http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/2992123.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/2992123.stm
- snagglegaggle 7y agoLook: Your ideas are misguided and dangerous. Read the article to see the effects of the guinea worm. The parasite ruins lives. The "not even wrong" was applied appropriately as the statement "there is some good to be had from keeping the guinea worm" is potentially true but practically unverifiable and is part of an argument whose goalposts can be moved easily and indefinitely, and are already so far away as to be unassailable. There is some value to biodiversity and its study and there are likely parasites that are beneath our radar but that this specific one can be isolated and studied and has recorded negative effects on humanity is enough to destroy it. >I'm reasonably sure that we will not find a tiny hitler inside the packets of 6 guinea worms, but if is really there, we could choose just not follow it Maybe studying the DNA of the guinea worm leads researchers to a breakthrough in targeting retroviruses at vulnerable human subpopulations and genocide is committed because we didn't exterminate it! See? You don't know that won't happen!
- Arubis 7y agoWe as a species cause the extinction of other species at such a rate that we’re considered on par with geologic processes (https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Holocene_extinction). I’m not here to argue that this is a good thing, but instead that, hell, let’s at least turn this terrible ability towards some good. Guinea worms and a. gambiae suck. The former causes pain and suffering without any detectable benefit. The latter is probably the biggest killer of humans, and there’s plenty of other stuff its predators can eat. Screw them.
- stallmanite 7y agoThank you. We drive species extinct left and right with hardly a thought. Now we need to be really careful about two that attack us directly and effectively?
- secstate 7y agoGood luck getting most of the crowd here to understand this perspective. I applaud your attempt at encouraging people to stop and think about things, but most people here seem to have grown up well protected from difficult things and think that if they try hard enough all pain and struggle can be removed from the path of humans through time. I just finished my chicken slaughter for the season; it being fall up in the Northern Hemisphere. I did my best to make sure the chickens didn't suffer too much, but killing is not a perfect science. I do know that they were really well taken care of compared to the wild birds around us for the last three months. I would never wish Guinea worm on anyone. I have first-hand experience with worm-based parisites and the pain/suffering they bring. It's awful. But life is a cycle, and belief in eradication of anything as a solution to suffering is, I believe, evil in it's truest sense.