5 ms·
I know I'm overly optimistic, but every time I see anything regarding legislation and "repair" keyword, i silently hope for a price limit on spare parts... and
by ajsnigrutin 7y ago
I know I'm overly optimistic, but every time I see anything regarding legislation and "repair" keyword, i silently hope for a price limit on spare parts... and am always disappointed not to see one.
If a new (whole) car(tv,washing machine,...) costs 20k (...) ($,€,..doesn't matter), and you want to replace some parts, the cost of just a few parts quickly becomes higher than a whole new unit. In a modern car, just replacing a few parts costs more than a whole car (both front lights ~1k(eur), rear ones 500eur, ac compressor 500eur(+), radio/navigation unit 1k, foldable mirrors 500eur, 'smart' rearview mirror up to 1k, etc...).
If the sum of costs of all parts to assemble a car is above 2x the price of the car, someone is getting ripped off, and we all know who that is.
Same with laptops... lcd assembly on a shitty 600eur laptop was quoted as 400eur+tax here (luckily ebay exists) - and that's without labour.
- ChuckNorris89 7y agoPrice limits would destroy capitalist freedom so never gonna happen. Good thing we have those on drugs at least.
- moksly 7y agoI wouldn’t say never, but it’ll take some time before millennials and below have enough political power to change our society. I think we’re going to see radical changes once that happen though, as we’re generations that haven’t seen the benefits of capitalist freedom, but instead have lived in constant worry of pretty much everything from finding a job and keeping it, an ever increasing retirement age even though some companies don’t hire people older than 35, a destroyed environment, impossible home prices and so on. Maybe I’m just living in a bubble, but I know no one my age or below who aren’t looking for change because the general consensus is that our current system is broken.
- isostatic 7y agoDepends how many millennials think they have something to lose by the time Be interesting to compare the change of vote as millenials grow into their 40s with the change of vote as hippies grew into their 40s. Remember the era of woodstock are now those 70 year olds voting for brexit and trump and burn the foreigners. Will today's Extinction Rebellion, or Occupy Wall Street from 10 years ago, change at the same level?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- fipar 7y ago> Remember the era of woodstock are now those 70 year olds voting for brexit and trump and burn the foreigners. Will today's Extinction Rebellion, or Occupy Wall Street from 10 years ago, change at the same level? I understand what you mean here but I think even back in the days when woodstock happened, the hippies were a minority even among their age group.
- antientropic 7y agoMillenials should keep in mind this quote from Milton Friedman: "We economists don't know much, but we do know how to create a shortage. If you want to create a shortage of tomatoes, for example, just pass a law that retailers can't sell tomatoes for more than two cents per pound. Instantly you'll have a tomato shortage. It's the same with oil or gas." That 400 euro price to repair a laptop might accurately reflect the labour and other costs. Repairing something is much less amenable to automation than mass-producing it in the first place (especially since the latter can be done in a low-cost country).
- kingbirdy 7y agoOP said the replacement screen was 400€ just for the part, not labor. Given the total cost of the computer is 600€ fully assembled that's obviously extortionate pricing for the screen.
- ajsnigrutin 7y agoJust the part was 400eur. probably 50-100eur more for labor. I got a used replacement on ebay for less than 100eur, and replaced it myself.
- tuxone 7y agoEspecially for cars, they sell you the product with a very low margin betting on high returns in after sales (spare parts). In the long term regulating spare part prices would likely result in an increase of the full product price. Not sure if it good to regulate prices here, maybe it make sense to leave this task to the market (see third party spare parts vendors).
- linuxftw 7y agoPatents, copyright, trademarks keep replacement parts high. Buying a car based on repair-ability and cost/availability of spare parts is a concern for many of us.
- megous 7y agoI think that price limits would not be very good. I'd worry about availability and creation of second-hand market, where third parties would buy out the supplies, to resell them later at higher price, before the manufacturer manages to re-stock the spare parts supplies. But I think mandating that replaceable parts have to be standardized, would make it so that multiple manufacturers would be using compatible parts. As a consumer/repairman you'd be able to choose which one to buy from. This would introduce competition that would put the pressure on the price. There would possibly be even less waste because standard parts could be more easilly reused with any fitting brand/manufacturer of the product.
- kube-system 7y ago> If the sum of costs of all parts to assemble a car is above 2x the price of the car, someone is getting ripped off, and we all know who that is. Not really. The business models are way different and have different costs. You're paying for someone to store that part, ship it in low volume to and from a parts warehouse, market to you, tie up capital in it, and gamble on the possibility that you'd want to buy it before those models go obsolete. If you buy 500,000 units via container ship from the factory you could get them for way cheaper too.
- deogeo 7y agoHow convenient then that manufacturers keep their costs secret, so we cannot verify such excuses for extortionate prices.
- kube-system 7y agoThe components and approximate values of these costs are well known; manufacturing is a well-established and stable industry. If you want some actual values, many of these companies are public and file financial reports: https://www.electroluxgroup.com/en/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2019/02/electrolux-annual-report-2018.pdf https://www.electroluxgroup.com/en/wp-content/uploads/sites/... Electrolux cited a 4.3% operating margin in their latest report.
- magduf 7y agoFor car parts, where are you getting your prices? Here in the US, there's usually online sellers of OEM parts that sell for much less than dealerships. Of course, even these can be pretty high, depending on the part in question. A lot of the parts you listed are things that should not ever be replaced, unless you have a wreck. If that happens, then part cost shouldn't be your concern, because insurance is covering it (hopefully, the other party's insurance). And finally, the used parts market is alive and well. Any of those parts can be easily found on Ebay for a fraction of the new OEM price. And on top of that, many of those parts have Chinese-made aftermarket replacements, which cost much less, and may be acceptable quality. As for the "smart" rearview mirror (I think you're talking about auto-dimming mirrors here), my Mazda came with one from the factory, but buying it afterwards costs about $300, certainly not 1k. Generally speaking, if the car is fairly new, you shouldn't be replacing parts like that except through insurance. If the car is old and you're trying to restore it, you should be looking for used parts. And if you have a new car and you're trying to add all the nice options to make it like the top-end trim model, then you're doing it wrong: you need to get the car from the factory with the options you want instead of trying to add them later, because that never makes any economic sense.