10 ms·
To play devil's advocate a bit: Consumers don't want to spend more for appliances. They want cheap. That's why manufacturers build the way they do (if you want
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
To play devil's advocate a bit:
Consumers don't want to spend more for appliances. They want cheap. That's why manufacturers build the way they do (if you want quality over 20 years you're already free to buy a Miele)
It is rare for an appliance to break down when just out of warranty, and in any case it is not possible to completely avoid.
I am glad that the new rules do not go farther then they do because I don't think there is an issue that warrant drastic action and widespread price increases.
There are plenty of ways to source spare parts and individuals are simply not able to repair themselves in most cases (and let's not forget health & Safety regulations).
Edit: Thank you guys for killing off any discussion...
- holri 7y ago> Consumers don't want to spend more for appliances. They want cheap. But there is not the consumer alone. The world, other people, the earth wants lasting appliances.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt's not obvious to me that current appliances are not lasting (and/or not repairable) and it's not obvious to me either that longer lasting appliances are necessarily better. Where are the end to end stats that show that this is better than recycling an old appliance to replace it with a new one that is more energy and water efficient? Where are the actual stats that show that breaking down just out of warranty with no parts available is a real issue? Also, there are no "other people" we all are consumers of these appliances.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- baroffoos 7y agoIn what possible way could using the same fridge for 10 years be worse than buying and dumping a fridge every 3 years?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoFridges don't break down after 3 years. Please let's have a serious discussion.
- martin_a 7y agoIn what possible way could using the same washing machine for 25 years be worse than buying and dumping a washing machine every 8-10 years?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoGreta Thunberg is not always there to tell you what to think... How about energy and water efficiency gains? How about materials used to manufacture? How about ease of recycling? A single use paper cup can be better for the environment than a sturdy glass... I simply do not buy that keeping an appliance for as long as possible is obviously better. This should be backed by numbers. In any case, the reality is that most people do not want to keep an appliance for that long. Manufacturers have adapted to that. Designing something to last 25 years when people will throw it away after 10 is a real waste, including for the environment.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 7y ago> Greta Thunberg is not always there to tell you what to think... Oh, you aren't actually interested in arguments? Why didn't you tell us earlier!
- hdfbdtbcdg 7y agoMine did.
- baroffoos 7y agoMine did. One of the PCBs was designed in a way that when the fridge light breaks it causes the whole pcb to fry and the fridge stops functioning. Thankfully we were able to get a replacement pcb because the manufacturer still supplied it.
- swish_bob 7y agoIf the current appliances are already set to last and be reparable, then the regulation is a NOOP as far as business is concerned. So there's an insignificant cost to the business, and the consumer's get some reassurance. Seems like there's no need to argue against the regs, then.
- chopin 7y agoI have a 3 year old Miele oven which needed one repair within the warranty period and another one just outside it. I am afraid Miele goes down the way of all the other manufacturers as the reason where parts which where shielded insufficiently from heat and moisture. In Germany, legislation has been proposed that manufacturers must label the expected lifetime. I am opposed to this as it may lead to stuff breaking down shortly thereafter. On the other side I would be fond of two things: All parts must be serviceable and a minimum period of spare part availability.
- ovi256 7y ago>manufacturers must label expected lifetime ... I am opposed Everything is already value engineered, designed for a specified lifetime, that's how we get those low prices and low material use. Labeling would just make it explicit. I work in an oil pipeline design group and even these things have expected lifetimes (30 years). So even megaprojects like bridges, skyscrappers, aircraft carriers, everything designed has an expected lifetime.
- fock 7y agoand I always thought, capitalism needs market transparency. Why not write it down and see what the customer does then, huh?
- Consultant32452 7y agoCompanies do write it down, in the form of warranties.
- close04 7y agoWarranty and expected lifetime are different concepts. The first is just a service that offers free repair/replace within a period of time. The second is how long you can expect the product to be in use, with or without repairs, until it reaches the end of its life. This can be either due to catastrophic malfunction, no available servicing parts or skills, or obsolescence. Think of a car that may have 3 years warranty but a service life of maybe 10 or more years.
- Paperweight 7y agoThe philosophy is to regulate unhandled economic externalities.
- kilotaras 7y ago> Consumers don't want to spend more for appliances. They want cheap. The consumer cannot easily distinguish between $400(dies after 10 years) and $300 (dies after 4).
- Joakal 7y agoSometimes it's more like $300 (dies after 10) and $400 (dies after 4). Why? The marketing trick to price a product higher to look like a premium compared to competition.
- adamlett 7y agoIt's hard to disprove that it is sometimes like that, but I would be extremely sceptical towards any claim that it is generally like that. I think it is safe to assume that price and quality are correlated in most cases.
- jdc 7y agoBased on what evidence, though?
- chopin 7y agoOnly anecdotal evidence but in my experience price and quality (as in lasting) are only very weakly correlated. In the past I tended to buy expensive (in expectation of lasting). The older I get the less I tend to do so even though I have now more money at my disposal. You're getting crap all the time independent of the brand.
- Gibbon1 7y agoI've noticed quality of ordinary things has been declining for a long time now. Some things are better due to new technologies. Lot of stuff has just regressed.
- denton-scratch 7y ago
- mozey 7y ago> individuals are simply not able to repair themselves in most cases This is the problem that needs to be addressed. The right to repair is not only about quality, price or durability. It is also a philosophical and strategic standpoint?
- TeMPOraL 7y agoThe right to repair isn't really about every individual repairing their own stuff themselves. It's about those individuals being able to ask their friends for help, or to bring the broken device to a local repair shop. That is, a manufacturer-unaffiliated repair shop. In this way, it's a fight for a more competitive, more free, and more distributed market.
- simion314 7y agoHonestly I don't think you gain more then a few dollars when you make the components a few mm thinner. I don't think the customers are a big force here, from my experience is the same part that breaks first but is there a strong enough incentive for the producer to investigate the issue and make that part stronger? If the customer will buy a new product or a new part that is extremely expensive then the producer is encouraged to engineer that part to break exactly when the warranty is over. I have a question, maybe someone here knows the answer, why are everyone make a new model each year that most of the time seems to be a redesign that brings nothing new, As an example I use same keyboard model and each time I buy a replacement it has changed a bit in design and internals, making them almost incompatible for salvaging components from one and fixing other)
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> I don't think the customers are a big force here Of course they are. Customers are not stupid, they know what they are doing. They know that a cheap appliance will last long enough and that "in 10 years I'll want to buy a new one anyway". > why are everyone make a new model each year that most of the time seems to be a redesign that brings nothing new Because that's what sells. You need 'new' to convince people to buy it, certainly to buy it at the same price it was last year.
- simion314 7y agoI disagree with you, let me give some examples that are not phones or computers where you can have maybe a different reason to buy a new model. I like the microsoft natural 2000 keyboard, it has a soft rest place that it scratches and in max 2 years it gets destroyed and the cable where it enters the case gets bent and used. So I now have 3 or 4 models that I bought over the years, there is no actual improvement, all the complaints in the reviews like noisy space bar were not addressed, just some small visual changes. So I am wondering why they did a new design,it probably costs a lot, did they found a way to gut 1$ worth of plastic? If we think at the environment and not at profits for the keyboard case there are 2 imediate things you could do: - sell the soft rest parts, there are easy to change if compatibility is not broken (i done it myself no special tools were needed but I transplanted them from a different one) - make the cable easy to replace (like you have with HDMI screens) so if I destroy the cable I can buy and just replace it rather then open the keyboard and find a different keyboard and grab the cable from that. IF the above would be costly to implement then maybe they can address the problem and make an improved design. Other example, I have a water pump, it has inside it a plastic/rubber balloon thing. This balloon will break every few months. I am wondering that they could make it 2 times more expensive and last 2 times more and it would be great because of the time and comfort lost when you have to replace it. But my waster time and confort plust he fact the old plastic thing goes into garbage is not factored in the producer calculations. So after this thing broke for the n-the time on me I would pay 10 times more and have it last 10 times more, I don't want cheap and bad but I do not have a choice. I admit there is a small chance that it is impossible to make this component stronger but this change is extremely small, probably the current one is the perfect balance for the producers and is at the threshold where the users won't give up and buy a new pump(you have no idea if a different model does not have same issue)
- edejong 7y ago> Consumers don't want to spend more for appliances. They want cheap. Many consumers are smart enough to understand that 'cheap' is a property calculated over the lifetime of the product.
- mrtksn 7y agoThe environmental aspect plays a big part in these things. These days it's popular to point out that the major polluters are not the individual consumers but the factories owned by the industrialists however these factories are not busy producing jewellery for the rich but stuff for the millions of consumers. Europe is very densely populated and well developed with much less developed neighbours which makes Europe very suspectable to environmental issues. If something bad happens in or nearby the continent, people in Paris or Rome can feel it through rent increase, a saturation of health services, an influx of people who somehow should be dealt with. If bombs go off in Syria things happen in Hungary. The place is very interconnected. EU has to deal with the protection of the environment just like any other issue that can cause large migrant movemenets. Throwing away things when you don't have to, inefficient appliances etc. are all stuff that must be addressed to preserve the peace in the continent. Europe's contemporary way of life is quite fragile.
- semi-extrinsic 7y agoThere's not just "building cheap", there is "building specifically to make things expensive to repair". Three years ago the main bearing in my washing machine broke down. Found a detailed video on Youtube for repairing the exact same machine, started disassembly. 45 minutes in, I discovered that in my machine that was a couple years newer than the tutorial, Bosch had plastic welded shut the drum, so you had to replace the entire thing. Replacement part cost went from $20 to $180 IIRC. Adding insult to injury, the flange in question had the bolt holes and locating features for the gasket still present.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoIt's not necessarily to make things more expensive to repair. Often, making things easy to fully take apart increases manufacturing costs. So there needs to be a trade off. Because of competition on prices, prices points, the fact the break downs are relatively rare. the priority is often to squeeze manufacturing costs.
- baq 7y agoand that's where regulation is especially helpful: in a race to the bottom situation, it moves the bottom up a bit.
- petra 7y agoSome of those changes are note very expensive. often times reliability is compromised for minor savings. The question is that of marketing. Can we make a marketing page that shows an easy to repair washing machine - and shows us that over 10 years, if we do the repairs ourselves - we'll save some money ? And the hassle of replacing to a new machine often ? At least some segment of the population, the DIY'ers may buy such machines.
- Freak_NL 7y agoI've repaired my then seven year old LG washing machine as well two years ago. The rear drum support had apparently developed a fault, and was nearly torn in two by the time the funny noises came and hinted at the need for repairs. The Youtube videos were a great help, but even though the part I needed was available, all the steps along the way to getting the part and fixing the machine made it clear that this was not a process aimed at consumers with the ability to repair such a machine. The manufacturer chose representatives in each country it sold machines in were you had to buy the part (at €100 with shipping not cheap, but acceptable), but the serial numbers never really matched exactly, and the model I had always had one extra letter left unexplained, making buying the part a gamble. The part fitted and the repair did work perfectly, even though I had to order the stainless bolts I needed to replace the worn originals from somewhere else (a web shop with a sensible interface). This device was seemingly designed to be repaired (or at least not prevent it), but documentation and lack of sensible part numbers made it harder then it needed to be. Interesting experience though, it feels good to extend the life of the machine by a few years this way.
- Certhas 7y agoYou argue as if protecting the environment was optional. And you start your argument with the hidden assumption that what consumers want should trump all other concerns. I don't necessarily agree with downvoting your post, but your argument _is_ poorly constructed. It seems to come from a place of reflexively opposing regulation, rather than thinking about whether this makes sense. In other words, I think people downvote because it doesn't seem to be in good faith, but ideologically driven.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoNo, I argue that protecting the environment should be based on facts and actual data, instead of being ideologically driven and that people's actual behaviour should not be ignored. My argument isn't poorly constructed, I commented to promote discussion not to be lynched. You are trying to second guess what I wrote too much. It seems very common here for people to try to see implied meaning everywhere instead of reading what is actually written. The sad reality is that it is not possible to think critically and to dissent on many topics these days. It is already decided what the correct opinion is, facts are irrelevant. Look at my comments in this thread: There are no reasoned replies to any of them...
- isostatic 7y ago> Look at my comments in this thread: There are no reasoned replies to any of them... You literally said "Greta Thunberg is not always there to tell you what to think"
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThis is a fact, isn't it? Try to think by yourself. The comment you're quoting from also contained 10 lines of arguments that you are ignoring, and instead you picked up that that line as if it was blasphemy. QED.
- baq 7y agowait what? I (not OP mind you) have been concerned with the environment since before Greta was even born. You just got a convenient face that happened to be at the right time in the right place to blame now.
- ahje 7y agoSorry, but that's just not true. If someone's spending 5000-10000€ on a kitchen renovation, then it's quite worth it to spend a couple of hundred more on appliances that will last as long as the rest of the kitchen. With modern built-in appliances then you need to take that into account, unless you want to install new cupboards every 5 years because your dishwasher died.
- tomatocracy 7y agoThey’re standard sizes and the mechanism to attach the built in doors to the appliances (where relevant) is also standardised. I’ve replaced built in fridges, washing machines, dishwashers, ovens and hobs in my own homes over the years without needing to redo anything else. What does annoy me though is that you have to pay a premium for appliances which are ‘built in’ over the equivalent model which is not built in, despite the built in version being less complicated (no door handles, for example).
- DanBC 7y ago> They want cheap. The UK had a catastrophic fire potentially caused by a cheap fridge freezer. White goods cause a few house fires. This page says 5 a day: https://www.electricalsafetyfirst.org.uk/media-centre/press-releases/2017/07/five-fires-per-day-caused-by-white-goods-in-england/ https://www.electricalsafetyfirst.org.uk/media-centre/press-... This page says 60 per week: https://news.sky.com/story/eight-house-fires-a-week-caused-by-faulty-white-goods-11250607 https://news.sky.com/story/eight-house-fires-a-week-caused-b... We need white goods to be safer, and people don't chose safer, they choose cheaper, so we need regulations.
- jonatron 7y agoThe safety reduction was mostly due to changing from non-flammable but o-zone depleting CFCs to highly flammable but non o-zone depleting refrigerants.
- ws66 7y ago> you’re already free to buy a Miele I want to buy Miele, or any other quality brand, but if anything breaks (which we know will happen), the service technician has a two hours drive to get to my place, which I have to pay. IOW, the top quality brands mostly offer service in densely populated areas (and it makes businesses sense for them)...