7 ms·
Battle to wipe out debilitating Guinea worm parasite hits 10 year delay
- cl0ckt0wer 7y agoSomeone watched the Politician
- dang 7y agoPlease don't post unsubstantive comments here.
- aristophenes 7y ago15 or so years ago I was in a remote African town and a local business had a picture of Gerald Ford up. Perplexed I asked why. The United States, I presume while Ford was president, had sent aid to build a bridge, some irrigation canals, and eradicated what he described as a worm that you pull out of your skin by wrapping it around a pencil and turning, an inch an hour. I guess it would have been this worm or something similar. Not a big deal for us, I'm sure hardly anyone outside the area heard of it. But for the locals it changed their lives, the food they could eat, the quality of life they could live. I'd say that I wish we did more stuff like this instead of the geopolitical games, but on another trip I found out that the majority of the Kenyan governments entire budget is foreign aid. Didn't seem to be doing much. But I knew some people from the USA who existed on donations that ran a free school for children, with meals out of a slum. They were poor in the US, but doing so much good. While the official NGO staff drove around in $50,000 SUVs to do surveys. Doing good is hard. Throwing money at something is not enough. It takes thoughtful, wise people and hard work. But there have been so many people pulled out of really bad conditions over the last few generations. Many many unsung heros.
- casefields 7y agoWe do. Bush and aids: https://www.history.com/news/what-was-a-george-w-bushs-greatest-achievement https://www.history.com/news/what-was-a-george-w-bushs-great...
- RobAtticus 7y agoIs it possible that the picture was Jimmy Carter? As the article mentions, the Carter Center has been leading this effort and Carter hopes to outlive the last guinea worm (though this timeline would make it difficult given he just turned 95 today). But perhaps both presidents have worked on it, just curious.
- refurb 7y agoreduced the number of new infections from 3.5 million per year in 1986 to just 28 in 2018 Jesus! They need to stop being so hard on themselves. That remarkable progress!
- sohkamyung 7y agoIndeed it is remarkable progress as this chart makes clear [1] [1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/global-number-of-reported-guinea-worm-cases https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/global-number-of-reported...
- jessriedel 7y agoYea, I sort of wonder how important it is to actually eradicate it. Like, how much would it cost to achieve eradication (given the new knowledge of dog transmission) vs. maintaining the current extraordinarily low infection rate indefinitely? Is the latter (on-going) cost cheaper than the interest on the former (one-time) cost? I'm sure this econ analysis has been done, but articles like these rarely mention it.
- tialaramex 7y agoEradication of Guinea Worm means no more Guinea Worm. Zero ongoing cost for all subsequent time. This is actually more substantive than for Smallpox because Smallpox is deliberately stored in a lab in case it is interesting (supposedly for defensive research, in practice for weaponisation) and so invariably every decade or four it'll leak. Guinea Worm isn't suitable for that, when they eradicate it that's the end of the parasite forever. This is an infinite benefit. So to model that without getting nonsense out you have to use a discounting model where you arbitrarily consider infinite future value to not be worth more than, say, 10 billion dollars, and there's your answer. But that's a paper exercise, why bother? You could choose values that say a trillion dollars or $9.99.
- vidarh 7y ago> This is an infinite benefit. So to model that without getting nonsense out you have to use a discounting model where you arbitrarily consider infinite future value to not be worth more than, say, 10 billion dollars, and there's your answer. But that's a paper exercise, why bother? You could choose values that say a trillion dollars or $9.99. It's really not that arbitrary. There are many ways of valuing this, sure. Here's a fairly straightforward one: Say it costs you A per year to maintain current levels, and the yearly cost of capital to eradicate is X amount of capital * y% yearly cost per year (e.g. if you borrow X at y% interest, or if you have X but sacrifice y% returns by spending the money instead of investing it), and the lowest viable cost to save at least as many lives as the infection currently claims is B, then it's a question of whether A+B or X*y% is lower. Whichever is lower will allow you to divert more funds to other targets, and so save more lives (or do something else). Of course there are risks here, in that any of the variables can change, so if they're close it may be worth it to eradicate simply to eliminate the risks that the alternatives get more expensive going forwards. But this is not a very hard thing to model. The reason we don't do that more often is that often there are many other factors involved, such as politics and emotions and who fights hardest to get funded.
- aaron695 7y agoLucky they have 100's of millions of militant people working to stop the mild discomfort from global warming in 60 years time. Youtube of Guinea worm, like many of these things stopping productivity and schooling can cause a cyclic issue - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCB1A2gFvuU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCB1A2gFvuU (2013)
- Kenji 7y agoQuotes from the article: A few years ago, it looked like humanity was about to wipe a debilitating parasitic disease off the face of the Earth. But the long road to eradicating Guinea worm just got a whole lot longer. Faced with evidence of previously unknown routes of transmission, the World Health Organization (WHO) has quietly pushed back the target date for stamping out the disease from 2020 to 2030. --- The number of new Guinea-worm infections in people has remained relatively constant in Chad, at about a dozen per year since 2010. (This year is an exception, with 24 cases — half of which came from a village where people drank from a contaminated pond.) Yet the number of new cases in dogs has climbed from hundreds in the early 2010s to more than 1,500 so far this year. “In Chad, it is clear that dogs are driving transmission and humans are ancillary,” Eberhard says. “If we control it in dogs, human cases might go away.” --- The eradication programme is offering a US$20 reward to anyone in Chad who reports a case of Guinea-worm disease in dogs. --- Plot twist: People are infecting dogs on purpose to earn 20$. Might be a profitable business.
- pvaldes 7y agoAs a counterpoint, it must be said that more than half of the life beings in the planet are parasites of other species. Wiping all of them would be a disaster for biodiversity conservation and a direct danger for humans. First, would make the populations of all agricultural plagues explode, populations of rats would increase also even more (but rodents would be much safer for humans). That would lead to choose between famine or free buffet of pesticides for all of us: breakfast, lunch and dinner. Second would have a profound impact on the development of our inmune system leading to people suffering a cascade of nasty autoinmune diseases. Parasites can have other benefits. Some clean the body of the host storing its heavy metals; other enter in open wounds and then feed on bacteria, releasing painkillers and substances that arre known to accelerate the healing of wounds. This avoid innecessary mutilations. The fine microsurgery made by some flies has been still not achieved by modern medicine and has saved lots of human lifes in the past wars. The reason for the disparition of many cases of guinea worm is wiping entire freshwater ecosystems
- dawg- 7y agoI thought the official definition of a parasite was an organism that benefits itself at the expense of the host? If the host gains from the relationship it would be called something else entirely. In that case, I think your statement that half of life on the planet are parasites is not really accurate...
- pvaldes 7y agoThe real number is unknown, because parasites are shared often among different hosts, but could be much higher in fact. Each species of free living animal known have at least one parasite, hosting 20 different species is not uncommon. Humans have several thousands just in the Platyhelminths group. Each plant known have at least two or three parasitic fungus. All known viruses except virulent bacteriophages are parasites, and is expected that most unknown viruses will be parasites also (we only had studied a small percentage of the extant viruses and there are serious estimates that calculate over 100 millions). Many bacterias also are parasites. Lots of fungus are parasites of animals also. And parasites have its own parasites.
- 7y ago
- pvaldes 7y agoAn interesting experience from this history is showing how parasites jump in zero seconds to a handful of other species when its main host is unavoidable. We were repeatedly guaranteed for years than Guinea worms were exclusive from humans. Thus wiping it would not affect any other species, and could be protected only if some humans would agree to suffer the parasite in their bodies, that is a gross price. Now we know that this was incorrect. Plain false, and nobody see it. The species is linked with other mammals, could be saved from extinction and is not different to a hundred thousand species of other parasites in the planet. To decide to wipe an animal just because is ugly and unsentient is a deeply wrong path and a pandora box. Treating the drinking water would suffice to prevent most cases in human patients. A similar problem could easily happen if we mess with mosquitoes without a full, extensive, complete, knowledge of what we are doing and asuming the consequences of it.
- mantap 7y agoI find this incomprehensible. It's a disease. What does it matter if it is bacteria, eukaryote or virus? Medicine involves killing things that interfere with us and hopefully eradicating them completely. The whole "mosquito extinction" fears are really overblown. Nobody is proposing to eradicate all species of mosquito - only the ones that carry malaria. And the normal system of eradication (removing standing water) is much more invasive than the proposed method of genetic engineering.
- pvaldes 7y agoNot, is not a disease, is an animal. An animal that can cause a non lethal and treatable disease in part of its life cicle, and is linked with copepods, frogs and fishes, dogs, baboons and humans. There is a simple solution in two steps to avoid being infected with guinea worms: 1) don't drink copepods. Provide african people living in the same distribution area as this animal with a modern system of water purification; or teach them to boil the water before drink it, so they will not eat alive water fleas that carry the larvae. Simply filter the water trough a cloth before drinking would be enough to protect you from this parasite (but will not protect against other problems so boiled water technique is much more safe). If not, use chemicals to treat drinking water. and 2) people infected by the parasite should avoid to bath in drinking water or put their wounded feet in drinking water. Life cycle stopped and end of the problem in the same year with the magic of parasitology Why we sould not run to extinct entire species? We don't know where hides the next cure for cancer, the next cool matherial for engineery or the next modern generations of painkillers. Parasites had helped in the past with some of our problems and could hold the key to a treasure of solutions to our present and future problems. Even if not, to randomly remove pieces of a machine could lead to unexpected consequences. This animal is the result of million years of evolution and when is gone, is gone forever. If we find in the future that some of those consequences are undesirable, the machine is beyond repair.