4 ms·
The fact that millions of people do a majority of their computing on their phone contradicts some of your argument. I also think it highlights one of the thing
by cortesoft 7y ago
The fact that millions of people do a majority of their computing on their phone contradicts some of your argument.
I also think it highlights one of the things this article misses; that one of the important design decisions is amount of effort the action takes.
Any interface that requires full body movement is going to be too draining to use all day. It is a lot easier to touch a screen than move your whole body to manipulate a thing, even if that would get you more fidelity.
For all the downsides of a touchscreen phone, people are able to use them one handed for hours on end.
- vortico 7y ago>Any interface that requires full body movement is going to be too draining to use all day I didn't say the ideal solution should take more effort than a touch screen. In fact, it will take less. Touching and dragging glass takes enormous effort compared to holding a stress ball and twitching your fingers in certain ways to control a computer. The ideal physical interface converts muscle power to "information control" with maximum efficiency. >people are able to use them one handed for hours on end Yes, to produce work they could have done in 10 minutes with a keyboard/mouse.
- cortesoft 7y agoMost people aren't 'producing work' when they are on their phone... they are consuming work.
- vortico 7y agoIn that case, I'm not interested in that use case. I'm interested in increasing efficiency and control of "producing work" on a computing device.
- cortesoft 7y agoMost of the time spent with computer interfaces is consuming rather than producing, though... doesn't it make sense to optimize for that use case for general purpose electronics?
- irrational 7y agoBut what percentage of the time spent on computers is producing versus consuming? I spend a lot of time producing (writing code), but I only do that on a desktop computer. My wife, on the other hand, spends almost no time producing and pretty much only consumes. In my experience, the vast amount of people are more like my wife (consumers) than like me (producers). Even my coworkers who are business people spend a magnitude more time consuming than they do producing. In my opinion, computer devices should be optimized to the most usual use case - consuming.
- munificent 7y agoIn my opinion, computer devices should be optimized for the world we want to have not the one we do have. Optimizing for consumption does not sound like a moral good to me.
- irrational 7y agoWhen you say "the world we want to have" I think you mean "the world I want to have" since most people seem to want a world where they primarily consume media. I think most people would say that the moral good is optimizing for consuming media, because that is what they want to do.
- TeMPOraL 7y agoMost people do a whole lot of things other than consuming media during their day, and computer technology is woefully underoptimized for all those other use cases.
- munificent 7y ago> since most people seem to want a world where they primarily consume media. 553,000 people in the US are homeless, but I don't think most would say they "don't want a home". 2.3 million people are in prisons, but I don't think that's the place they "want to live". 15.1 million have an alcohol abuse disorder, but I don't think they would all characterize it as "wanting to drink". 12 million people in the US experience rape, violence, or stalking from a partner every year but I wouldn't characterize them as "wanting to be in that relationship". Behavior reflects all sorts of things outside of the person's intentions and aspirations. One of the goals of a just society is to give people a framework that helps them reach their goals.
- ColanR 7y agoThat may simply be the result of an interface that doesn't let them be efficient or productive.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- ddingus 7y agoExactly. I actually do a lot of work on my phone. I have a pen model, and I sometimes break my bluetooth keyboard pointer rig. Few people will bother. The UX takes real work to make productive.
- Chris_Newton 7y agoFor all the downsides of a touchscreen phone, people are able to use them one handed for hours on end. But do they achieve more in all of those hours than they could have achieved in only minutes with better input devices and more powerful software?
- cortesoft 7y agoA lot of the time their goal is to make time pass faster, which is not something you can speed up.
- xenocyon 7y ago> For all the downsides of a touchscreen phone, people are able to use them one handed for hours on end. You actually picked an example that doesn't support your argument very well: back in the day, people were able to manipulate dumbphones one-handed very dexterously and even without looking (famously, teens could text their friends while their phones were hidden in their pockets) whereas the modern smartphone demands the use of eyes and often both hands. One-handed use with most modern phones is much more difficult and error prone than with the dumbphones of yore.
- TeMPOraL 7y ago> famously, teens could text their friends while their phones were hidden in their pockets Confirmed. I could do that, because all the keys had a small set of functions and input delays were entirely predictable (a benefit of running soft real-time firmware instead of a "regular" OS). And, of course, they were all actual keys. It's easy to develop muscle memory in such conditions.
- ddingus 7y agoNot really. Tons of people, myself included, use the crap out of mobile phones. I had to do real work to get good at Android. And I am. Can do amazing things on my picture behind glass thingy. Of course mine comes with a pen. Made some tasks possible and practical. That said, I pretty much hate it. The thing demands a lot of attention. My older tactile device didn't. Like the other comment says, tactile interfaces can be used in pockets, etc... I do not know what the future holds, but leaving grease smears on a touch screen probably is not it.
- atoav 7y agoI am not sure how widespread usage correlates with ergonomics and I am afraid it doesn’t. And before you get a wrong picture: I wrote big parts of my last academic thesis on my smartphone while I was waiting on the bus. I’d like to use your argument against you: it is a lot easier to have your hands rested on your desk and just move your fingers a few milimeters on a keyboard than it is to hold your hand in mid air and move it around on a screen and it is faster too. Only downside: harder to learn and the mapping between keys and actions is often unclear. I have been working professionally as in audio editing and I cannot imagine doing that on a touch screen. I don’t want to frantically wave my hands around the screen like a conductor just to get a fraction of the speed that I would have when using a computer keyboard. I also have a direct comparison between software modular synths and the real thing. Software can in a sense be more flexible, because you can just place down 10 effect nodes without having to own them, but the cabling is far more exhausing than with a physical cable (unless we talk about presets or removing all cables). Touchscreens certainly also have their applications where they outperform every other interface, but it depends entirely on the task.
- dkersten 7y ago> Touchscreens certainly also have their applications where they outperform every other interface, but it depends entirely on the task. Agreed. I love my ipad for a lot of entertainment type tasks and I feel the touchscreen works great for that: most general web browsing, watching youtube/netflix, listening to music (touchscreen for browsing/creating playlists), some types of games (but IMHO fails miserably at most). Drawing is great with a stylus, but IMHO not so great with my finger. For everything else, give me a proper physical tactile keyboard and a mouse, or physical buttons/knobs/faders/whatever.