They're not in support; they're reserving their judgment, staying neutral. They did the comparison only to show how goatinaboat's appeal to trust is a logical

They're not in support; they're reserving their judgment, staying neutral. They did the comparison only to show how goatinaboat's appeal to trust is a logical fallacy. Before coming to a judgment, one should take the facts at hand, instead of relying solely on the trust you have of the people involved like goatinaboat did. In this case, many details cannot be seen, so it's not proper to decide on a judgment solely on the fact that we trust Monica.