5 ms·
I swear, I half wonder if some of these questions are just outright trolling. It's hard to imagine a company actually being this stupid. Yeah, let's take one of
by mindcrime 7y ago
I swear, I half wonder if some of these questions are just outright trolling. It's hard to imagine a company actually being this stupid. Yeah, let's take one of our brightest and hardest working people, communicate to them that their hard work and effort are useless, and then bitch when they quit putting in overtime. Brilliant.
If this story is real, I think the OP (of the SO question) needs to accept that the fuck-up is on the part of his/her company, and quit looking for ways to "discipline" their engineer.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Blakestr 7y agoI am half with you - but I can totally imagine a company being that stupid, they just wouldn't phrase it as simple and direct as you did, so they don't see the stupidity. The mandatory 3 year "derisking" period sounds asinine. If you can't evaluate an engineer's ability to solve problems in 12 months for a position, I think that's a bigger issue. Conspiracy theory - Article is written by the "overeager engineer" who is looking for clever ways to respond to his company's asinine policies.
- zmmmmm 7y ago> The mandatory 3 year "derisking" period sounds asinine I don't have too much sympathy for the OP on stackoverflow, but I do think 3 years in a company of 5000+ people is not that long to wait to reach a senior position. It's not just about tech skills, at that level it is personality too. It's pretty important at senior levels that people are not just going to up and leave on a whim, so to my mind a 3 year type period is quite a reasonable test of whether they are long term suitable in the company.
- sneak 7y ago“Complain” or “gripe” works just like “bitch” with none of the misogyny.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoand then bitch when they quit putting in overtime. That's not really a fair characterization. He's actively and obviously investing in building his own brand, as it were. He's further doing so in a very in-your-face manner, plus encouraging others to do the same. It's almost like an undeclared work-to-rule style strike. This is potentially a real problem for the company. Personally, I think the real issue here is their reluctance to fire him over the cost involved. Keeping him may cost far more. Granted, they probably should have done something different somewhere along the way to avoid this entire scenario, but I don't have any idea what that might be. I don't have enough information to guess.
- mindcrime 7y agoHe's actively and obviously investing in building his own brand Which is exactly what he should be doing, as we all should. He's further doing so in a very in-your-face manner Great, sometimes you need to make a point. plus encouraging others to do the same. Good, that's a win for everybody, except the short-sighted management that want somebody who will "go above and beyond" without any reward for it. It's almost like an undeclared work-to-rule style strike. This is potentially a real problem for the company. And a problem the company brought on themselves. And one they could fix by working with this guy and giving him more than the proverbial "pat on the head". If they really can't promote him right now, it's hard to imagine that there isn't something they could do to appease him and tide him over. More money? Extra vacation time? Company car? New title? Guaranteed lunch with the CEO twice a year? I dunno, but most people are reasonable and it seems unlikely to me that they couldn't find some kind of compromise if they really wanted to.
- DoreenMichele 7y agoI'm not saying you are wrong. Just saying your characterization is a tad understated, let's call it. He did more than just quit putting in overtime. I mean, it was fifteen hours a week. That's a lot of OT to do on a regular basis. Management is often an ass about how OT gets handled anyway. They often have stupid, counterproductive policies in that regard.