3 ms·
Well, I disagree despite the condescension (which isn't as disarming as you think, btw). Qs on a Q&A site become a sort of permanent record that other people s
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
Well, I disagree despite the condescension (which isn't as disarming as you think, btw).
Qs on a Q&A site become a sort of permanent record that other people stumble across, not just a wham bam thankya ma'am transaction that only the Q-asker sees. By revealing XY problems, a better service is provided for everyone who stumbles upon the Q.
> Goodness me, why is this so difficult?
Because not everyone agrees with you. This faction war has been going on at SE forever.
- ratww 7y ago> Qs on a Q&A site become a sort of permanent record that other people stumble across The fact that it is a permanent record that lives on is another argument in favor of the "just answer the damn question". Context changes. Requirements change. Someone in the future might need the exact answer for some reason, but instead they get some useless back-and-forth and low-effort condescending answers that is super-specific to that asker. Asking for more context, adding disclaimers before answering or linking to alternative solutions in the comments is fine, but it's a pain in the ass when the answers doesn't match the questions.
- rusk 7y agoI think you've illustrated the grandparent's point perfectly! (in a pleasingly condescending manner too - I might add!)