3 ms·
We aren't here to just answer your homework question. Why you're doing something is part of the conversation and its context. It's also part of asking a good q
by hombre_fatal 7y ago
We aren't here to just answer your homework question. Why you're doing something is part of the conversation and its context.
It's also part of asking a good question. I don't understand the uproar especially on a Q&A site.
- mjw1007 7y agoThis behaviour is particularly bad on a Q&A site that aims, as SO claims to do, to optimise for future readers (rather than the individual asking the question). It leads to a page with a clear question at the top and a great deal of text below which is not an answer to that question.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 7y ago> Why you're doing something is part of the conversation and its context. ...and is often a way to shift the conversation to an argument about why the asker is doing it that way instead of giving them the information they actually asked for. I don't have time to argue about the sequence of events and layers of requirements that led to me asking the question, it doesn't matter if this "isn't the right way" to do it, it's the way I need to do it.
- mark-r 7y agoOften the best answer will depend on that seemingly off-topic information though.