6 ms·
This “verified” nonsense is silly. Twitter knew who Assange was but refused to “verify” him. They should change what they call verified to another label like
by mc32 7y ago
This “verified” nonsense is silly. Twitter knew who Assange was but refused to “verify” him.
They should change what they call verified to another label like “goodie two-shoes” instead. As it is is a complete misnomer. It’s basically used to get users to behave a certain way and if they don’t conform they don’t get verified or if they are verified it gets revoked.
- srbby 7y ago"verified" means "good citizen of the platform"
- mc32 7y agoAlternatively “top revenue generator, except where we disagree with them, except when we make special exceptions”.
- collyw 7y agoTo me it means "person full of their own self importance".
- yjftsjthsd-h 7y agoThat might be necessary, but it's not sufficient; there are many users who are not "verified" who are very convinced of their own importance;)
- collyw 7y agoAgreed, but a check mark confirms it for me.
- vortico 7y agoWhen will Twitter re-open verifying? It's been closed for 2 years...
- uptown 7y agoThey still do it when they want to.
- slig 7y agoPeople with the right connections are getting verified.
- apostacy 7y agoCrummy Buzzfeed content drones with 5000 followers are getting verified. Verification ticks are just a badge of being well connected, and approved. And having your tick removed is a way of saying that you have stepped out of line.
- cameronbrown 7y agoThat's what worries me about verified. It's just a form of nepotism at the end of the day and they certainly prefer certain niches (Hollywood, Silicon Valley, the media industry, etc..) over others.
- cwkoss 7y agoAlso seems verified is fairly correlated with certain political ideologies - kind of feels like twitter is trying to direct conversation without taking responsibility for bias.
- Faark 7y agoThat sounds like the usual persecution complex of the anti establishment/alt right. If that where the case, Twitter would be very shitty at such job, since countless of them are verified. Notably including alex jones up to his ban.
- cwkoss 7y agoJournalists of major publications and celebrities are pretty evenly verified. Maybe it's just the circles I follow, but I encounter a lot of random 'liberal centrist with a podcast who has written 2 op eds'-types that seem to be more famous on twitter than anywhere else.
- XJ6 7y ago"Verified" ceased to be meaningful as actual verification as soon as "unverified" became a thing. I think making it a brand-coloured tick conveyed too much of a positive message so people took it as an endorsement, leading to pressure to "unverify" if that person did or said something bad. Given that action, the "verified" tick then becomes an even stronger signal of endorsement. Perhaps it would be better to call them "Partners" like on Twitch and make it an explicit contract with revenue kickback.
- waterhouse 7y agoI can think of one use case for de-verifying: when someone's account seems to have been hacked.
- JorgeGT 7y agoThey have painted themselves into a corner with this feature. They cannot call it "partners" because you cannot claim to have a partnership with, say, the US Navy and the President of Iran (both "ticked" in Twitter) nor give them revenue kickbacks, and yet, it's not really an ID verification if you "de-verify" people for their political or commercial stance. AFAIK Twitter is so confused by this conundrum that they just froze the "tick" program (or so they claim). Of course they could abandon all pretenses and just call it "ticked" accounts without saying what it means at all...
- jfk13 7y ago
- sschueller 7y agoYoutube recently decided to change their requirements to become verified. They emailed existing verified users that they no longer meet these requirements and therefore will loose the "verified" status. Completely insane.
- zadkey 7y agoMXR mods had this exact problem on youtube.
- nilkn 7y agoFor what it’s worth, my understanding is they were actually trying to fix the situation but users conceptualize being “verified” as a sign of status and so got upset. A lot of YouTubers are currently “verified” for whom there is no risk of mistaking them for a clone account. The only real point is for YouTube to verify the channels of actual celebrities who will get lots of copycats and are known off the platform.
- sschueller 7y agoBut if your ID has been "verified", why would you all of a sudden no longer be verified unless the verification was fraudulent? To verify yourself on instagram etc. you need to submit identification etc. . Once you have done that there should be no reason to take that away from you if valid. You are still you unless maybe you get married and your name changes which could require a re-verification and if the policy was changed that you don't qualify for verification it would be fair for you to be no longer verified.
- dwild 7y ago> But if your ID has been "verified", why would you all of a sudden no longer be verified unless the verification was fraudulent? From what I understands, the previous verification was merely reaching 100k, nothing more. I wouldn't call that fraudulent, but considering many people may expect it to means that their identity was actually verified by Youtube (and not that they simply reached a milestone in subscription), I wouldn't call that being verified. > To verify yourself on instagram etc. you need to submit identification etc. . Once you have done that there should be no reason to take that away from you if valid. I agree, but we aren't talking about Instagram now, but Youtube.
- AliAdams 7y agoMaybe "Trusted" could be be a better alternative to "Verified".
- blotter_paper 7y agoIf a President were caught in a lie, would the "Trusted" status be removed? If not, what would the "Trusted" status even mean?
- mc32 7y ago“Lie” is too strict. Everyone is caught making false statements. Everyone would get “distrusted.”
- falcor84 7y ago> Everyone is caught making false statements That is too postmodern for my tastes. I would strongly argue that one can speak without making false statements, and would be very much in favor of some sort of fact-checking badge on social media. It would be difficult, but I really believe it would be worth it.
- Mountain_Skies 7y agoWho watches the watchers? So far pretty much every fact checking organization, regardless of original intent, eventually succumbs to the temptation to bend their fact checking to their ideological preference. There is no social media company that has the credibility to even be taken seriously as a impartial arbiter of fact.
- stickfigure 7y agoYet everyone does not like equally, not by a longshot. We have sites like snopes and polifact. Maybe not perfect, but better than postmodern nonsense like "there is no truth".
- DoofusOfDeath 7y ago> They should change what they call verified to another label like “goodie two-shoes” instead. I agree with your main point. On a tangent: I'm not sure "goodie two-shoes" is quite the right term. I would argue that by helping to expose illegal actions by the U.S. government, Assange was a poster child for "goodies two-shoes".
- mc32 7y agoI kind of get your point, but generally speaking a goodie two-shoes doesn’t rock the boat and is more of a pleaser (to authority).
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- giancarlostoro 7y agoWorse a musician I followed on Instagram got hacked. There's no way to report "This account has been hacked." or any sort of custom report. I had to pick a random one which was then denied. I don't understand why they don't have sane security settings for verified accounts, otherwise what's the point. The musicians a Christian to had gone to jail and used to do drugs and speaks out against those things, the person who took it over has 666 on their name and other inappropriate things which is adding salt to the wound. If your account can get hacked and never retrieved, what's it worth being verified?
- KoftaBob 7y ago"verified" has essentially become the social media equivalent of airline companies' "preferred members".
- apostacy 7y agoAll this nonsense started with online agitators from Breitbart. Instead of having the gumption to just ban people like @nero, they instead unverified him for some reason. Probably because he was making money for them.
- fulvous 7y agoBan him for what?
- aqme28 7y agoConsider also https://twitter.com/AlbertEinstein https://twitter.com/AlbertEinstein It's not a long-dead scientist, but is still verified as such.
- 1f60c 7y agoIt says it’s managed by his estate—it seems fine to me?
- dfxm12 7y agoI disagree. I mean, it's fine that Einstein's estate is tweeting under his name, but that shouldn't satisfy Twitter's definition of verification. Verification means: The blue verified badge on Twitter lets people know that an account of public interest is authentic. [0] It's not authentically Albert Einstein (which is objective), nor do I see how his estate posting science news from who-knows-where is of public interest (this is subjective, and there is enough grey area that it makes for a weak policy). If an account is verified, Twitter should also explain why. This explanation could be in the users' bio. 0 - https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/twitter-verified-accounts https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/twitter-ve...
- cwkoss 7y agoThat is really disgusting that they are verifying dead people. Even though his estate authorized it, seems like a betrayal of his legacy to allow someone else to present their speech from him. I hope the US soon passes legislation banning impersonation of the dead unless they explicitly authorized that use while alive. Similarly Erica Garner's account is verified and was taken over by one of her friends after her death. Some controversy after account tweeted things in direct contradiction to what Garner said while alive.
- rolltiide 7y agoThe checkmark status should be like that. It should be like an voluntary stricter license with arbitrary conditions set on content creators. They just need to articulate what those conditions are. The lack of being direct is what is hurting them here, and also not communicating what “verified” actually means, because it doesnt mean “you are popular and important” it just means “you are an aspiring LA model or aspiring SF tech CEO that both perform for Saudi money”