3 ms·
> It's a pattern of behaviour over years combined This is a tough rhetorical device. I’ve read quite a bit about this recently. I am not a huge RMS reader and
by prepend 7y ago
> It's a pattern of behaviour over years combined
This is a tough rhetorical device. I’ve read quite a bit about this recently. I am not a huge RMS reader and while I’ve known of him for 25 years or so, I haven’t nearly read everything he said and everything written by people who met him.
So maybe he does have a pattern of behavior that’s negative enough to be fired. But maybe he doesn’t have a pattern but some people incorrectly perceive a pattern. It’s tough without proper data to differentiate.
What I have read is a half dozen accounts of not really clearly defined “charges” like “he asked me out once” and “someone told me that women at MIT keep plants to wars him off” and “he made jokes about virgins.”
Granted, I don’t know the method for cancellation but even if everything I read on HN is true. If every story ends up being completely accurate in the most negative way possible, thats like 20 things over 40 years. And not a pattern unless implicitly add in much more.
I think that these anecdotes are useful if I’ve already decided RMS is a misogynist and I want to back in some evidence. But I feel like if this were given to a jury of his peers he would be acquitted
It also seems weird to me how these few stories are presented as evidence as if they count for a lot. That’s scary as I’m not sure how anyone can defend themselves against faulty evidence. Or even to determine if it’s faulty.
So we run the risk of going into a weird mob event where only negative evidence can be presented. There is no defender. There is no real judge.
This is not a healthy way to treat people. And I don’t think it’s a good way to produce good software.
- stochastic_monk 7y agoJury of peers is for criminal prosecution, not job performance assessment, which is closer to civil cases, in which preponderance of the evidence is the standard.
- prepend 7y agoThere’s a judge and sometimes jury in civil cases. There’s still evidence rules. My comment stands with preponderance of evidence standard. I feel like if all this was handed to a judge or jury it wouldn’t meet the standard for civil verdicts either. It’s only when I see this stuff presented in the tumbler verse world of most uptweets is true or whatever that it seems to stick. It’s certainly currently effective, but I don’t know how sustainable it is because it seems like a poor way to produce quality things. Perhaps there will be a critical mass of people who just adhere to a rational ideal and break the boycotts to the extent where we can have a parallel world that ignores such style of medium-post fueled discussion.
- roenxi 7y ago> This is a tough rhetorical device. There is no particular charge to defend so it is indefensible. It is more insinuation than accusation. It also sounds vaguely convincing without needing to provide any actual evidence or cite any specific instance, and turns singular instances of not-really-a-problem into a 'pattern' (eg, like what happened to his door sign). > But maybe he doesn’t have a pattern but some people incorrectly perceive a pattern. I went to a Stallman talk on Free Software once when he was in Australia. The questions he fielded after the talk where honestly jawdropping and one of the first encounters I had with how little some people understand subtle arguments. "Software must be free, but people can be paid to work on it!" then "So what you are saying is that people should work without getting paid?" style exchanges. Stallman is defiantly no stranger to having his words misunderstood. It wasn't even malicious, people just didn't understand him.