3 ms·
I fail to follow your first argument. How would something that is good for plant life be bad for life on the planet? Plants form the base of the food chain. Vi
by chrisco255 7y ago
I fail to follow your first argument. How would something that is good for plant life be bad for life on the planet? Plants form the base of the food chain.
Virtually all modern plants grow at higher rates right up to 1200PPM. I'm not sure how taller trees and taller grasslands would affect us negatively.
Presumably, more plant life means more animal life. As there is more food to support ecosystems.
- adrianN 7y agoIf you keep temperature and humidity controlled, like in a greenhouse, more CO2 is better for plants. It's completely unclear whether the dramatic changes that global climate change will bring will be similarly beneficial to the plants we have today.
- masklinn 7y ago> How would something that is good for plant life be bad for life on the planet? Because it's only "good for plant life" in the very long (geological) term. In the short and medium (again, geological) terms it's a significant upheaval which is good for pretty much nothing. > Virtually all modern plants grow at higher rates right up to 1200PPM. I'm not sure how taller trees and taller grasslands would affect us negatively. The 1200 PPM CO2 and associated effects would do that, especially in the short-term, it would take tens of thousands of years[0] for new ecological equilibriums to be reached during which the entire web would be broken. > Presumably, more plant life means more animal life It would mean very different animal life. The intermediary period would be mass deaths across the board. [0] at the very least, could be millions depending on the scale of disruption, it took ~2My for the ecosphere to stabilise after K–Pg, and a further ~8My for it to recover pre-K-Pg levels of diversity. Local disruptions are easily resolved as species can migrate from neighbouring non-disrupted ecosystems but global disruptions (of the entire ecosphere or of a very isolated ecosystem) not so.
- chrisco255 7y agoPlants respond immediately to higher CO2 in artificial greenhouse environments. It would be both a short term and long term change. A study on PPM experiments with 3 grass species: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5799915/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5799915/
- masklinn 7y ago> Plants respond immediately to higher CO2 in artificial greenhouse environments. Cool I'm very happy for your environmentally controlled greenhouse. Outside the greenhouse, CO2 levels affect more than just plant growth. When the entire climactic pattern and of an area changes, which plants (and animals) can thrive in it also changes, the old ecosystem is destroyed and it takes time for a new stable ecosystem to establish itself. And the faster the original disruption the more difficult the transition is.
- MayeulC 7y agoThat is a false equivalence. To take it to the extreme, water is the base of life on earth. So adding an extra 2km of water on earth's surface couldn't possibly be bad for life, right? And it wouldn't necessarily. The thing most of us are concerned with, is to preserve our ecosystem as we know it. Part of it is bebause we know it can sustain us (selfishly). Another part is, fast changes are hard to adapt to, and fast changes in the environment have already sparked multiple mass extinction events. And ecosystems are complex and interlinked. They are flexible to an extent, but something that's good for part of the ecosystem isn't necessarily good for the rest; it's easy to have it all collapse (this is documented, as we have witnessed multiple local ecosystem collapses over the years, and it's quite simple to imagine). Of course, what you say is also true. But, for instance, how do the same plants grow in warmer temperatures? With less water? Without the usual organic life in the soil? Our ecosystems are not so resilient once we stress them too much, too quickly. Our current way of life is just irresponsible. Let's stop burying our heads in the sand, and come up with rationalizations that arise from cognitive dissonance (which I suspect is what drove you to write this post).
- NeedMoreTea 7y ago10% faster growth could easily mean 10% fewer nutrients per kilo of food. "We know unequivocally that when you grow food at elevated CO2 levels in fields, it becomes less nutritious" https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ask-the-experts-does-rising-co2-benefit-plants1/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/ask-the-experts-d... Rising CO2 means reducing performance for humans and other animals. Not a huge problem if you're an agricultural worker working fields near sea level. For those in offices, cities and especially at higher elevations it's simply going to increase the chances of problematic concentrations.