3 ms·
This argument for antinatalism never made any sense to me. A casual glance at history will show you that it’s easier and cheaper to raise children today than at
by keiferski 7y ago
This argument for antinatalism never made any sense to me. A casual glance at history will show you that it’s easier and cheaper to raise children today than at pretty much any point in time, except perhaps for middle class white Americans ~1955-1990. What’s changed is the (perception) that keeping up with the consumerist Jones’ is somehow required to have a family.
- JauntyHatAngle 7y ago>middle class white Americans ~1955-1990. Isn't that where most people get their idea of family life from?
- Arnt 7y agoI don't know about you, but I got my ideas mostly from my parents, and the parents of my friends while in school.
- JauntyHatAngle 7y agoAnd a large amount of their perception is influenced by the dominant media, which I'm hypothesising generally pushes the idea of a middle to upper class nuclear family as being the norm.
- pytester 7y agoDid the cost of rent, medical care and college go down?
- keiferski 7y agoNo, they've gone up - but my point is that the baseline costs for raising a child in average, decent-quality conditions (in today's terms) are still drastically lower than even the lowest of salaries. We've simply come to expect all kinds of consumerist goods as "required." Furthermore, even a "poor" childhood today is materially leagues above the average child of 100 years ago. That's not to say we should aim to return to that, but simply that there are a lot of "needs" which are really "wants." Housing is a good example. Yes, housing prices in coastal cities have spiraled out of the reach of middle class people. Yet, there are thousands, even tens of thousands, of affordable cities all throughout the South and Midwest. The "problem" with those areas is that they are perceived as undesirable places to live. Again - a want, not a need. The issue of inequality is a separate one and not the direct point that I am making. I'm simply saying that throughout all of human history, people were far poorer and yet still had children. Even today, the majority of the world's population is poorer than the poorest in the west. Clearly the main reason Western people aren't having kids today is not because they legitimately can't afford it - there are other cultural factors at play.
- pytester 7y ago>No, they've gone up - but my point is that the baseline costs for raising a child in average, decent-quality conditions (in today's terms) are still drastically lower than even the lowest of salaries I don't see how that can be if the core costs - rent, medical care, education have all skyrocketed. Diapers going down in price by 15% doesn't really help if at the same the price of college goes from $15k to $150k.
- keiferski 7y agoAgain, a college that costs $150k is a want, not a need. There are plenty of opportunities to go to community college, gain credits in high school, etc.
- pytester 7y agoEven if you do consider college a want (which is highly dubious in today's wage earning environment and with competition from globalization that didn't exist before), rent and medical care are the furthest possible thing from want.
- keiferski 7y agoAgain, rent in cities that aren’t the hot, desirable coastal ones is quite reasonable and has been for a considerable amount of time. And as I just mentioned, there are a plethora of ways to earn a college degree without spending $150,000.
- pytester 7y ago>Again, rent in cities that aren’t the hot, desirable coastal ones is quite reasonable Wages are shit in a lottt of those places. Rents are reasonable as a % of SF programmer income I suppose, but the picture is a little different if it's mostly walmart jobs or nothing available.
- watwut 7y ago
- Kaiyou 7y agoChildren used to be a help, because they could work much earlier and had to on farms. So it made economic sense to have them. The incentives have changed.