2 ms·
Hold on, I'm confused. This isn't allowing anyone to arbitrarily add any Stellar key to somebody else's profile or anything, is it? (And thus redirect actual m
by crazygringo 7y ago
Hold on, I'm confused.
This isn't allowing anyone to arbitrarily add any Stellar key to somebody else's profile or anything, is it? (And thus redirect actual money?)
It's just generating a new Stellar profile/key for each Keybase user automatically, and affirming that it belongs to each Keybase user?
Hardly seems like a backdoor, just a mildly annoying/unwanted marketing partnership. Actually not even partnership -- since Stellar is now funding Keybase, just cross-product promotion? [1]
[1] https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-stellar https://keybase.io/blog/keybase-stellar
- sneak 7y ago> affirming that it belongs to each Keybase user Falsely/fraudulently affirming, using a cryptographic signature silently and non-consensually generated, yes. Those keys it claims are mine are not; I have no knowledge of them. The claim is incorrect, unlike each and every other item on my profile page, which I explicitly signed. This is the same concept of a backdoor as when a messaging app signs a wiretap key without the user's consent or knowledge. The same thing has happened here. It's one thing to get "their username on GitHub is 'x'" wrong. It's another thing entirely to say "you can send real, actual money to this person at AN ADDRESS THAT BELONGS TO THEM, 'x'", when I have no knowledge of the keys for that payment destination and no desire to receive such payments; it is blatantly fraudulent that their software has used my private keys to sign and publish such a statement. Would you tolerate an email client that silently changed your checking account or routing number on an outbound email before PGP signing it?
- rcthompson 7y agoEdit: My comment took at face value the OP's claim that the Stellar account was generated without their knowledge. Obviously, if that claim is false, as Keybase's official response indicates, then my comment is invalid. Original comment: It does seem more than a bit questionable that the Stellar account is added automatically to the user's profile among a list where every other account/key/whatever in that list was manually added by the user. (As pointed out by the OP)
- aeternum 7y agoThe affirmation part is the problem. Generating trustworthy signatures is a critical part of a cryptographic system. Signing something requires access to the user's private key. If that key can be used by other entities to produce signatures, it is no longer private and can no longer be trusted.