4 ms·
That's why it's called "moral high ground" instead of "most profitable way to sell out".
by DenisM 18y ago
That's why it's called "moral high ground" instead of "most profitable way to sell out".
- simonw 18y agoPhilosophical question: would it be moral for Mozilla to cancel that deal and then have to lay off half of their staff?
- thorax 18y agoYeah, it'd be moral to correct for mistakes like that, but very unfortunate for the employees. I have very close friends who work at Mozilla. I wouldn't wish that on them at all. Still, they came to Mozilla because of its integrity and role. If it was explained to them that Mozilla can only remain independent of corporate influence by re-evaluating their stance on issues like this, I think the employees would understand and many of them (hacker-types) would continue working on the open source projects (as before) when they could. Difficult situation, though, no doubt.
- dannysullivan 18y agoLook, Google can easily say they like Mozilla, want to fund it with a $100 million per year and that they want to back their stated goal of protecting user choice by saying they do NOT want to be the default but rather one of several choices that a user actively selects from. Mozilla wins, Google wins, users win. But bottom line, if Google is for choice in IE, then it should be for choice everywhere.
- josefresco 18y agoGreat comment, except Google and Mozilla are too busy counting their millions to care.
- gojomo 18y agoMaybe MSFT hasn't ponied up the same $$$ as Google and Yahoo to appear in Firefox? I don't think a nonprofit that battles MSFT should have to give them free valuable promotional space, and conversely MSFT may not want to fund a competitor.
- pg 18y agoAny organization that gets revenues from some illicit practice would presumably have to fire people if they stopped. So if preserving jobs is sufficient reason to keep doing something, no organization should ever stop doing something bad, as long as it remains profitable.
- josefresco 18y agoDenisM I have to say I think you and I are alone on this. The chorus of "shhh Mozilla is making millions on this" is drumming out logical debate.
- gojomo 18y agoCompared to the reinvigoration of browser competition and standards-compliance that the Mozilla project has achieved, this issue is a minor quibble. You can add Microsoft and many others with a few clicks. Someone has got to be the default, and selling preferential placement means this project, an important counterbalance to MSFT, gets around 1/1000th the revenue of MSFT. Let MSFT outbid Google for the top spot if they want. MSFT doesn't need anyone's charity.