12 ms·
I suspect that Starship will fly to space before SLS ever will. I also think Starship has a significantly higher chance of flying at all than SLS.
by philwelch 7y ago
I suspect that Starship will fly to space before SLS ever will. I also think Starship has a significantly higher chance of flying at all than SLS.
- DanCarvajal 7y agoStarship could have Falcon Heavy level of delays (which I think it will) and still beat SLS.
- nexuist 7y agoNot entirely sure about that. Have no skin in the game but from what I can tell Starship is just a bigger version of the Falcon 9 second stage. FH on the other hand required a lot of engineering investment to figure out how to bolt three F9s together and how to make the software work between all three. I'm certain it will be a long time until it can get to Mars, but LEO within the next 2-3 years is probably realistic.
- kanox 7y ago> Starship is just a bigger version of the Falcon 9 second stage No way, that's where most of the differences are. The Falcon 9 second stage is a classic expendable stage but Starship is a brand new design which aims to be fully reusable.
- nordsieck 7y ago> Starship is just a bigger version of the Falcon 9 second stage Starship is designed to land from interplanetary speeds (not just LEO orbital speeds), can re-fuel in orbit, and has the world'd most advanced rocket engines. The jump from F9 -> Starship is substantially larger than the jump from F9 -> FH. edit: spelling
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- JshWright 7y ago> I can tell Starship is just a bigger version of the Falcon 9 second stage What similarities are you referring to? They're designed to be launched atop another, bigger rocket. Other than that...?
- caconym_ 7y ago> from what I can tell Starship is just a bigger version of the Falcon 9 second stage I know I'm piling on here with this quote but I just don't understand why you'd say this if you'd done the least amount of research. They are about as different as two rockets can be—do you think Starship is "just a bigger version" because it's an upper stage? Because it's built by the same company? Its design and (theoretical, until it flies) capabilities are radically different and expanded relative to F9 stage 2.
- cryptoz 7y agoFH was 5 years+ behind schedule before it was built and launched. Starship already has multiple constructions going on, with multiple prototypes to test and multiple full-size vehicles planned quickly. In 2011, FH was supposed to have "arrival at launch site" by 2H 2012. It first launched in 2018 (after arriving at launch site in 2018 not 2012). The same level of delay would mean the first Starship does not reach orbit until ~2025. That seems crazy pessimistic and would be a dramatic departure from the otherwise normal delays faced by SpaceX. I think it's extremely unlikely that Starship would face FH-level delays. That would cancel the Starlink constellation, cede the space-internet game to others, hand the torch to BO or others working on large projects, and absolutely destroy morale at SpaceX. I just don't see it happening.
- ethbro 7y agoMinor: Boeing is BA, if that was the reference
- justapassenger 7y agoFH is "just" 3 F9 strapped together. Doing that took them more than 5 years than planned. Keeping that in mind, having 5 year delay on brand new design, using totally different materials, new engine, etc isn't far fetched.
- cryptoz 7y agoThere is a quote somewhere (by Elon?) saying that FH is not "just" 3 F9s strapped together. A significant source of the slowdown for FH was the desire to not launch it without full reusability of all 3 stages and not to launch it without significant improvements (block 5 etc). Starship has none of those potential delays and has already solved most of the hard problems (as evidenced by the Hopper hopping already). Starship has all of the learnings and experience that FH and F9 didn't have. There will be delays, sure. But we won't be waiting 5+ years again for a single launch. Those days are over, and SpaceX is proving it. Some context, I haven't read this yet: https://www.quora.com/What-makes-SpaceXs-Falcon-Heavy-more-than-just-three-Falcon-9-rockets-strapped-together https://www.quora.com/What-makes-SpaceXs-Falcon-Heavy-more-t... Edit: > Keeping that in mind, having 5 year delay on brand new design, using totally different materials, new engine, etc isn't far fetched. The first full size Starship prototype is already built though (within ~2 years of initial announcement? Not behind schedule basically at all, so far?). IIRC for FH it was a ~5 year delay before SpaceX even starting construction on the first parts. The difference with Starship is staggering. The pace is dramatically faster, the risks are reduced up-front, and the tests are planned on a much shorter timeframe. We would frequently go 6 months to a year and hear no news at all about FH. There is news, updates and progress available to the public on an hourly or daily basis about the Starship progress. Night and day.
- de_watcher 7y agoStarship looks stupid simple compared to the FH.
- nickik 7y agoI think people are missing an important point when talking about Falcon Heavy. Yes it was delayed, but the Falcon Heavy that was eventually launched, was WAY, WAY better then the one announced in 2011. The payload of the 2011 version was almost reached by the Falcon 9 itself. That was one of the major reasons for the delay, not design and production issues. The Falcon Heavy profited from all the advancments on Falcon 9 and it made no sense to actually build a Falcon Heavy before Block 4. In fact the first costumers for Falcon Heavy flew on Falcon 9 instead.
- brandonjm 7y agoIt is certainly a little bold of Bridenstine to comment on other space companies being behind schedule given NASA’s own delays.
- frankharv 7y agoWell when you tell a customer you will have all hands on deck and then are out back playing with your go-kart then expect your billion dollar customer will say something.
- brandonjm 7y agoI imagine all the necessary hands are already on deck for Crew Dragon. Starship wasn’t built by the Falcon or Crew Dragon manufacturing teams, and the vast majority of the design and engineering currently happening for Starship has long been completed for Crew Dragon. Let’s also remember that NASA is hardly the only company that pays SpaceX, they have other income sources and what they do with that income is ultimately their choice. Unless they are using NASA money to build Starship there should be no problem.
- frankharv 7y agoFrom this[1] article: "Musk said in 2018 that SpaceX was “all hands on deck for Crew Dragon,” and it would be making trips to the ISS by December 2018. After that, he said, “most of our engineering resources will be dedicated to BFR, and I think that will make things go quite quickly,” he said. BFR was the earlier name for Starship." "All hands on deck" is not some subjective term, it is naval and means get everyone on deck now to repel boarders. [1]https://kfor.com/2019/09/28/nasa-administrator-tells-elon-musks-spacex-its-time-to-deliver/ https://kfor.com/2019/09/28/nasa-administrator-tells-elon-mu...
- sgc 7y agoExcept there is nothing they can do now. There are a ton of safety reviews which depend on NASA, and only a small amount of people at SpaceX are required to keep the NASA team more than filled with work. Elon responded saying he would do whatever it took to go faster, but there was nothing he could do.
- SomeOldThrow 7y agoFor reference, SLS refers to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System FWIW SpaceX is exactly the kind of phenomenon that might spur state investment.
- caconym_ 7y agoTo me the SLS is like Brexit: obscenely wasteful and short-sighted, seemingly inevitable, but somehow I still don't believe it will ever leave the ground. The Artemis thing is like a joke for real, though. After the last 30 years of bullshit we've seen from the US government's manned space exploration efforts I think I'll be living in a SpaceX-manufactured igloo on Titan before Richard Shelby and his obstructionist, pork-slinging ilk manage to put footprints on the moon.
- oska 7y agoJust as a comment: I really hate seeing Brexit dragged into every conversation. We're talking about rockets here, which should be a million miles away from any discussion of Brexit.
- nickik 7y agoYes. Thank you. Brexit is the ultimate 'this proves my world view' and gets dragged into every conversation.
- caconym_ 7y agoPlease enlighten me: what's the world view I'm trying to prove by invoking Brexit?
- caconym_ 7y agoThe SLS is pure politics. You're welcome to ignore that, if you like, but that decision means you won't have a good understanding of why the rocket "exists", or why it's designed the way it is, or what the prospects are for its future.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]