4 ms·
Twice. Their loss, twice. Edit: You guys below are taking "their loss" too seriously lol. Is it really their loss? Who knows. Do I think it's their loss?
by benologist 16y ago
Twice. Their loss, twice.
Edit:
You guys below are taking "their loss" too seriously lol. Is it really their loss? Who knows. Do I think it's their loss? Sure.
- solipsist 16y agoDid you submit the same application both times? Was it platomic?
- benologist 16y agoYep, although it was originally called SWFStats. Now I'm tracking 10 billion events a month in real time, and I'm armed with tons of awesome users, some friends and an increasingly solid strategy for capturing a few more markets. :)
- dotBen 16y agoThe fact that you've gone on to be successful doesn't mean that they 'failed'/'lost out' because they didn't back you. For a start it could be that the startups they did back have gone on to achieve even more (or they expected to). You're calling it as if it is black and white, and it isn't. Still, I hope you continue to see success in your venture.
- zachallaun 16y agoYC definitely lost out, and I'm sure that pg (and the others) would be the first to admit it. Any good VC or Angel knows they can't always make the right call. In fact, I'm fairly confident that YC has that written down somewhere. Possibly in multiple locations.
- aaronbrethorst 16y agoIn theory, pg has already 'admitted' it to ben twice, now: We realize this process is fraught with error. It's practically certain that groups we rejected will go on to create successful startups. If you do, we'd appreciate it if you'd send us an email telling us about it; we want to learn from our mistakes. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=70062 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=70062
- benologist 16y agoOf course they can miss stuff for a whole stack of reasons, and it's not even certain they have made a mistake - I just assume they have and everyone who's not accepted should do so too, to think otherwise about your own startup would be retarded heh.
- wmboy 16y agoIt doesn't mean YC failed, but he does have some bragging rights all the same. The truth is, a lot of startups have been accepted into YC and have achieved far less...
- apedley 16y agoI agree it doesn't particularly mean they lost out, but well done for getting your startup off the ground without VC support. It can be much better for you in the long run anyway. Although now that you have a business going some VC support might enable you to expand quicker.
- ScottBurson 16y ago"It's their loss" is definitely the right attitude to have, whether it's factually true (how could one ever know?) or not. Good for you!
- robryan 16y agoYour product looks like a definite winner now, when you applied though I'm guessing there was a lot of work to do and it was a lot less clearly a winner?
- benologist 16y agoYeah it was a lot smaller just 12 months ago: http://playtomic.com/blog/post/46-looking-back-on-2010 http://playtomic.com/blog/post/46-looking-back-on-2010