6 ms·
>Once a human learns chess, you can give it a 10x10 board and she will perform at nearly the same skill level with zero retraining. Interesting. Has this actu
by jayd16 7y ago
>Once a human learns chess, you can give it a 10x10 board and she will perform at nearly the same skill level with zero retraining.
Interesting. Has this actually been shown? I would assume a lot of the strategies a human is familiar with would fall apart as well. I'm no chess or go player but I would have to learn new strategies in a tic-tac-toe game scaled to 10x10. I would certainly not be as proficient although I would still consider myself to have intelligence.
- mindgam3 7y agoAlmost all of the human strategies and concepts would still apply: center control, square control, development, initiative, king safety, the opposition, etc. The only exceptions would be fringe concepts like opening theory (already moot in Chess960) and endgame edge cases. If you’re still not convinced, I’ll prove that skills transfer by playing bullet against anyone who can make a 10x10 variant playable online. [Edited to come across less egotistical]
- csande17 7y ago> make a 10x10 variant playable online I'm not saying I'm definitely going to do this, but is there a rulebook somewhere for 10x10 chess? (What are the initial piece positions, and how would castling work?)
- mindgam3 7y agoI’m not aware of 10x10 chess ever being attempted, let alone codified. Here’s my suggestion: add another set of bishops (or knights, or one of each) in between rooks and king/queen. Castling works the same, king goes around rook.
- gpm 7y agoGeneralized NxN chess is a thing I've seen talked about in complexity theory. I'm not sure if anyone has actually made a proper set of rules for it though. It looks like they often just don't care about such trivialities as starting positions (and probably castling). E.g. http://www.ms.mff.cuni.cz/~truno7am/slozitostHer/chessExptime.pdf http://www.ms.mff.cuni.cz/~truno7am/slozitostHer/chessExptim...
- jhncls 7y agoFormer world chess champion Capablanca suggested a 10x8 board with two additional pieces in the 1920s, but there have been many variants proposed earlier and later [0]. Grand Chess [1] is the most known 10x10 variant, also with 2 additional pieces and a different start position, castling not allowed. See wikipedia for links to programs implementing these rules. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capablanca_Chess https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capablanca_Chess [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Chess https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Grand_Chess
- mindgam3 7y agoInteresting. Note that both of those types involve introducing new pieces. I would argue that this changes the fundamental nature of the game in a way that increasing board size alone doesn’t. The reason is that I (as a human chess master) would need to retrain myself to learn the new piece movements. What I really want is a 10x10 or even 8x10 board using the original set of pieces. This would be sufficient to prove that human chess masters can adapt in a way that machine-learning based algorithms cannot.
- qiqitori 7y agoWouldn't adding more of the existing pieces in the back row change the game a bit too? Which piece(s) would you suggest having more of to accomodate the extra fields?
- mindgam3 7y agoIt would change the game but not enough to reduce the performance gap between an expert and a novice. See my grandparent comment for a specific suggestion on which pieces to use.
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoThere are variants with fewer pieces like Hexapawn: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexapawn https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hexapawn
- m0zg 7y agoI'm pretty sure this isn't how chess masters actually play chess. That'd be too slow and error prone. They pattern match very heavily in the beginning and towards the end. And all those patterns would be wrong on a larger board with more chess pieces. At least for chess.
- mindgam3 7y agoI hate to break it to you, but this is exactly how chess masters play chess. Including bullet. Source: am a master, rated 2500 in bullet.
- m0zg 7y agoYet you yourself also mention openings and endgame above in the thread. What's that if not pattern matching?
- mindgam3 7y agoWait, are you referring to the comment in which I refer to them as “fringe concepts”, “already moot”, and “edge cases”? Please don’t attempt to twist my words in order to support your own bogus position. Act like a chess master and just resign already.
- m0zg 7y agoI'm not a chess master myself, my knowledge of this topic is from what I've read of Kasparov. The guy is all about patterns. He even advises to play using a physical board as much as possible, to improve _visual_ recognition of patterns. Thing is, you might not even recognize this as "pattern recognition" per se. Call it "intuition", call it "experience", or whatever you like, but combinatorially I'm pretty sure you're not searching the entire tree of possible positions several moves ahead - that's literally impossible to do for a human to do in the finite time allotted to a game. You're relying on patterns to constrain the search, much like a modern neural algorithm would constrain its search using a cost function. That's what's meant by "pattern recognition" here, not rigid recognition of fixed positions. That is also combinatorially impossible for a human to precisely memorize.
- tzs 7y agoPerhaps a better example than 10x10 chess would be bughouse chess [1]. That's a chess variant played between two teams of two players using two sets and two clocks. It's a common break activity between rounds at amateur chess tournaments. Human chess players of all levels pick it up pretty fast after they play a handful of games. [1] Detail on bughouse in this comment from an earlier discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20831586 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20831586
- YeGoblynQueenne 7y agoWhy stick to chess? Magic: the Gathering is a game that is played with cards with printed rules text that describes how a card should be played. The set of cards is constantly updated with a few hundred new cards introduced at least twice a year (although games are often played with only a subset of all cards). Despite the constant change of the card pool, and also the wording of the rules text on the cards, and the rules themselves, human players are perfectly capable of "picking up a card they've never seen before and playing it" correctly. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic:_The_Gathering https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic:_The_Gathering