7 ms·
Why The Public Radio is sixty dollars (2018)
- imglorp 7y agoThe price is a good conversation about globalizing supply chains. But what's really cool is they have a way to program radios which are sealed inside a cardboard shipping box, without batteries installed. https://wp.josh.com/2017/03/18/capacitive-coupling-casestudy-programming-the-public-radio-without-removing-it-from-its-sealed-shipping-box/ https://wp.josh.com/2017/03/18/capacitive-coupling-casestudy...
- pencerw 7y agoYeah, Josh's method of tuning The Public Radio is super cool. We never actually implemented it in production, but our manufacturing line is in some ways even cooler (it's fully just-in-time) and is remarkably advanced for a FM radio in a mason jar :) I wrote it up in a separate blog post here: http://pencerw.com/feed/2018/2/8/the-public-radios-assembly-fulfillment-processes http://pencerw.com/feed/2018/2/8/the-public-radios-assembly-...
- charliesome 7y agoThis is an interesting post from the perspective of logistics operations for a small scale consumer electronics product. I'm fascinated by the idea that one of the features they chose to cut from their initial release - arbitrary tuning - has ended up significantly constraining how they can manufacture their product at their scale. I'm guessing that there's a deeper philosophical reason for not building an end-user tunable radio that isn't simply "it's a feature we decided to cut so we could ship on time"
- StevePerkins 7y agoThis product just seems... like a throwback to the first decade of this century. A time when we rebelled against over-advertised, and over-priced Gillette Fusion cartridges. Not by growing beards (that would come in the 2010's). But rather by shaving with $100 German double-edge razors, badger hair brushes, and artisial shaving soaps instead. This here is a cheap pocket radio, like you could find at Walmart for $5. Except that it is built to tune into only one frequency, it has no headphone jack, and its form-factor is a old-timey mason jar. It's "artisanal", and "locally-sourced" and all that, and it does look like a pretty conversation piece. But do people still gravitate to stuff like this? I'm asking from genuine curiosity, because I'm not sure whether the "hipster" era faded away, or if it's still there and I just grew a little too old?
- asperous 7y agoIn business school we have a framework for understanding customer needs.. jobs to be done (functional, emotional, social). In this case the "job to be done" is probably not really to listen to news/music (there's a million better things for this). Likely it's emotional.. decoration, nostalgia, "toy" Therefore alternatives to this product are not other radios but other fun decorations, throw back items, or simple electronic devices. -- For modeling I think this is similar to "the light phone" that also did well on crowd funding. So I think there is a trend here.
- macintux 7y agoAs wonderful as my smartphone is at accomplishing a billion different tasks, occasionally I want something that does exactly one thing and does it well. For many years I listened effectively to just one radio station, and something like this would have indeed been delightful. I could see using this to rekindle my love for public radio.
- shantly 7y agoSee also: tiny houses. Mobile homes or RVs were too low-class, I guess. Not enough hand-planed teak or whatever. Tiny home, now that signals you've attended higher education and have made a thoughtful philosophical choice rather than just being poor. eyeroll
- i_am_proteus 7y agoA Merkur 34 costs $40 and blades are $6/100. I broke even vs. cartridge razors in three months, a decade ago. This is not a throwback to the safety-razor hipster era of yesterday, this is a manifestation of the artisan-chic post hipster/hipster-yuppie/yupster reality of today. Alternate take: in an increasingly complicated world, people are coming to value simplicity and aesthetics, and will pay for these things.
- tim58 7y agoChiming in on shaving. The double-edge safety razor can either be something that's cost saving compared to Gillette or an expensive hobby. I personally know people that spent $750 in shaving equipment, only to go back to an electric Phillips within five years.
- Aloha 7y agoI'm an avid radio listener, literally every room in my house with a power outlet has one or more tabletop radios in it. Why would I want a radio that only tunes to one channel? I tend to use vintage (80's era) clock radios at home for my tabletop radios, because of their decent pricing.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- pstuart 7y agoMaybe you're not the target market. I only listen to radio in the car, so I'm not that market either. That said, it's a brilliant idea and I can see the appeal to many who do listen to one public station all day.
- Aloha 7y agoI mean I do only listen to one station all day, I virtually never change the station, but I like the ability to do so.
- lxe 7y agoI am impressed if this business works. You're selling something for $60 with the same functionality as something I can get on Alibaba $0.30-$1 per unit. And the people are buying it because of all the artificial restrictions.
- pencerw 7y ago(Note: I co-created the product, manage the business that produces it, and wrote the original blog post) In many ways I'd say the answer is still in flux. On the one hand this is a part-time business that has not, by any means, made either myself or my partner rich. On the other hand, we sold our first units in 2014 and are in continuous production today. It's a weird side business to have, but we've figured out a way to make it fit into our careers/lives. In other words, I'm continuously surprised that The Public Radio continues to be a _thing_ and am always slightly shocked when I see one in the wild. And it's nice to have something like that.
- vyrotek 7y agoFor those confused as I was, you can switch the current station but it's not convenient or meant to be done often. You can basically disassemble the radio and press a button to cycle through available FM stations and leave it on the one you want. Why this button isn't just available on the lid is beyond me. While I do appreciate simplicity I really don't understand the value of a single station radio either. > https://www.thepublicrad.io/faq https://www.thepublicrad.io/faq
- leoedin 7y agoIf it had a button on the lid, it would just be another FM radio - not really a market that a small hardware company want to be in. The statement this radio makes by being untunable is literally the only reason anyone buys it.
- vyrotek 7y agoBut it is tunable which breaks the whole 'statement' for me.
- pencerw 7y agoThat's fair, but if I were to guess I'd say only 5% of our customers are even aware that the radio is re-tunable. It's not a secret by any means, but we don't really promote it and even if you did once know about it you could easily forget that it's an option at all.
- hatfortguy 7y agoI really like this. The fact that it's re-tunable makes this reusable for people who would otherwise have to buy a replacement and throw this one away. We recently moved house and had to return our radio, even just to stay on the same station (they broadcast on slightly different local frequencies across the country to overcome local noise). I'm seriously considering buying one of these but wouldn't be if it wasn't reprogrammable; I'm not into throw-away electronics because of the environmental impact.
- arbuge 7y agoThe key part seems to be this: > In other words: We’re making a piece of consumer electronics just-in-time in the US. It is indeed hard to bring down costs that way, but when each unit needs to be individually programmed, as in this situation, this is a sensible way of doing it. This is also a good way to do low volume production in general for hardware side-projects and the like. My own Relay (https://foundrytechnologies.com/relay.php https://foundrytechnologies.com/relay.php) is made in the same way - the components come from China but the assembly and firmware upload is done in the US. This also keeps the firmware confidential, which works well for IP protection. For higher volumes, I'd think we'd eventually move the assembly offshore, but not the firmware upload.
- kennywinker 7y agoI'm constantly surprised that people aren't more alarmed at how much china owns the supply chain. It's virtually impossible to make electronics without at VERY LEAST buying components from china. Seems like a lot of power in their hands. For example, I'm deeply uncomfortable with doing business with china because of the million Uyghurs in concentration camps - but if I want to buy simple passive electronic components to populate a circuit board I've got no other choice?
- zw123456 7y agoI think it would be a good promotional gift for public radio pledge drives.
- dredmorbius 7y agoApparently it is: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21108556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21108556