4 ms·
Successful large scale fusion energy is not enough. It must be cheap enough to replace hydrocarbons and be viable within reasonable time scale. If the cost and
by nabla9 7y ago
Successful large scale fusion energy is not enough. It must be cheap enough to replace hydrocarbons and be viable within reasonable time scale.
If the cost and time scale does not matter, fission is already good enough. People are just irrational and can't compare things. Fukushima type accident every few years would be completely acceptable and compared to coal and hydrocarbons.
- Lazare 7y ago> People are just irrational and can't compare things. Fukushima type accident every few years would be completely acceptable and compared to coal and hydrocarbons. You're quite right, but keep in mind that identifying the problem doesn't make it go away. If public opinion won't accept fission, then we'll need another option even if fission is technically a fine solution.
- pjc50 7y ago> Fukushima type accident every few years would be completely acceptable and compared to coal and hydrocarbons. This is the most delusional thing I've ever read about nuclear feasibility. No country will ever accept more than one of those.
- cthalupa 7y ago>No country will ever accept more than one of those. They won't (and shouldn't, since it should be preventable), but the fact of the matter is that coal power plants kill a hell of a lot of people, and recurring Fukushima style events are still less detrimental. They're just significantly flashier, and that makes them scarier.
- missosoup 7y ago> No country will ever accept more than one of those. And yet most countries accept death toll and land area denial orders of magnitude higher every single year to keep operating coal plants and ICEs. As a randomly sampled person, you are almost certainly going to live less because of the use of hydrocarbons and you are almost certainly completely unaffected by the use of nuclear power. This is the same effect as car crashes being just a death toll yearly statistic that everyone accepts, meanwhile each individual plane crash is subjected to news theatrics despite flying being orders of magnitude safer than driving. Australian mining industry destroys one of the natural wonders of the world spanning 344,400 square kilometres just while doing business as usual? Meh. Second worst nuclear disaster of all time results in 371 square km exclusion zone where people are still safe and wildlife is thriving and with 0 casualties? Stop everything. Ban nuclear.
- ageofwant 7y agoIt would, if people were rational and could do basic math. So you are of course right, but not because coal is saver, its demonstrably not, its because nuclear fear is a cultural affliction ingrained in the psyche of modern civilisation, and its going to cost us our future. We can be carbon negative in a decade and multi-digit negative in two, allowing us to sequester carbon released from humanities previous carbon age. All using well understood save nuclear energy. Modern breeder reactors will take nuclear energy from being orders of magnitude safer than coal, to even safer levels. And we can do this today, with boring old fission.
- nabla9 7y agoAll countries accept much bigger death tolls. Just the radioactivity released to air from burning coal is much bigger than Fukushima. Never mind that Coal causes almost all deaths by other means than radiation. Consider this: 1.069 PBq/yr Radioactive release from annual coal combustion. 600 PBq - Upper limit of radioactivity released from Fukushima accident. Actual may be half of that. > No country will ever accept more than one of those. Because people are irrational as I said. source: http://nuclearaustralia.blogspot.com/2011/12/coal-1-fukushima-every-6-months.html http://nuclearaustralia.blogspot.com/2011/12/coal-1-fukushim...