3 ms·
That's not the definition of subjective. When GP says "That’s not subjective; you just made it up." it means that talking about airplane safety (which can obvio
by hn_throwaway_99 7y ago
That's not the definition of subjective. When GP says "That’s not subjective; you just made it up." it means that talking about airplane safety (which can obviously be objectively measured with things like crashes per landing/takeoff, crashes per mile, etc.) with the moniker "it's subjectively the safest" doesn't make any sense.
It would be like saying "That plane is subjectively the heaviest" or "Today is subjectively the hottest day on record" - no, it's not subjective, you just made it up.
- samstave 7y agoI completely disagree with this. I subjectively make my statement based on that data I have available to ME* Objective would be I have failure data in front of me. Now, I personally have heard of far fewer B-52 accidents in my lifetime, and the plane is almost double mine, and as such, I deem it safe as heck. Also, guess what - B-52s carry nukes not passengers. How many nukes have gone off for a B-52 crash vs how many lives have been lost via commercial crashes? Also, I come from a nuke family, and an air force family. My grandfather was one of the designers of Hanford and my brother was head of the tenth medical wing and flight surgeon to the joint chiefs, and my dad best friend was sec of energy... in charge of nukes... So, I stand by my words.
- azernik 7y ago> and the plane is almost double mine I assume you're talking about lifespan? The B-52 may have been in the air for a long time (though only 15 years longer than the 737), but it has also been flying in much smaller quantities; there have only ever been ~750 B-52s built, while there have been over 10K 737s built. And in addition, a commercial airliner is usually in the air for a much higher percentage of its lifespan than any military airplane. So for example, the 737-600/700/800/900 series has had 9 accidents (6 full-loss equivalents)... over 100 million flights. http://www.airsafe.com/events/models/rate_mod.htm http://www.airsafe.com/events/models/rate_mod.htm Accident rate info for the B-52 is harder to come by, especially since a lot of the "accidents" are complications from battle damage in Vietnam, but I'm seeing 10 peacetime full-loss incidents just among those that have their own Wikipedia pages: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Accidents_and_incidents_involving_the_Boeing_B-52_Stratofortress https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Category:Accidents_and_inciden...
- samstave 7y agoThank you for a thoughtful response. I come to HN to share ideas and thoughts, but typically just get a bunch of self righteous assholes... and ive been here for quite a while. Youre not allowed to be wrong on HN and it makes me resent the community. I love to admit if i am wrong, as it means i am learning something. So i appreciate you fixing my perspective. My perspective came feome the fact that a single plane could have been flown by three separate generatjons of pilots (which i have seen happen with the B-52) and that they have been carrying nukes about for the past 50 years and that we havent seen a singular nuclear accident with them. Not so much that we havent lost any aircraft themselves. But HN is the most pedantic community ive ever encountered in all my years. But at least it keeps things honest.
- azernik 7y agoHN doesn't appreciate confident arguments that are based on zero or anecdotal evidence. It also doesn't appreciate goalpost-shifting (from safety record in terms of crashes, to in terms of nukes going off (???)). More generally, fanboyish rants about how $FOO is the best $BAR ever made tend to draw particular attention. And lastly, complaining about downvotes is in the actual guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html > that they have been carrying nukes about for the past 50 years and that we havent seen a singular nuclear accident with them. As other commenters have noted, this is more a testament to the phenomenal safety of nuclear weapons; they've been blown off the top of exploding ICBMs, hit the ground and the water at high speeds in crashing bombers, and generally gone through a LOT of abuse without going off.
- tempguy9999 7y agoIIRC atomic explosions are intrinsically difficult things to set off. I suppose the lensing explosive might go off and blow around nasty chunks, particulates, metal vapour perhaps, without actually producing a nuclear explosion of any sort. (IANA nuke engineer)
- 7y ago
- BurningFrog 7y ago> That's not the definition of subjective Merriam Webster's definition(s): Definition of subjective (Entry 1 of 2) 1: of, relating to, or constituting a subject: such as - a - obsolete : of, relating to, or characteristic of one that is a subject especially in lack of freedom of action or in submissiveness - b - : being or relating to a grammatical subject especially : NOMINATIVE 2: of or relating to the essential being of that which has substance, qualities, attributes, or relations 3 - a: characteristic of or belonging to reality as perceived rather than as independent of mind : PHENOMENAL — compare OBJECTIVE sense 2a - b: relating to or being experience or knowledge as conditioned by personal mental characteristics or states 4 - a(1): peculiar to a particular individual : PERSONAL subjective judgments - (2): modified or affected by personal views, experience, or background a subjective account of the incident - b: arising from conditions within the brain or sense organs and not directly caused by external stimuli subjective sensations - c: arising out of or identified by means of one's perception of one's own states and processes a subjective symptom of disease — compare OBJECTIVE sense 2c 5: lacking in reality or substance : ILLUSORY