4 ms·
It is reasonable for governments to want to be able to wiretap communications. They can wiretap telephones, including mobile/cell phones, for example as this is
by mytailorisrich 7y ago
It is reasonable for governments to want to be able to wiretap communications. They can wiretap telephones, including mobile/cell phones, for example as this is built into those systems. There is no problem with that and it is actually welcome.
Those apps that provide end-to-end encryption are a problem and they are working on solving it.
Claiming that they should not be able to wiretap lawfully (or even otherwise) is a rather naive view of the world and lawful wiretapping does not imply dystopia.
- sidlls 7y agoLawful wiretapping does not imply dystopia, but the actual practice sure seems to. This is very likely to be abused by enforcement agencies and politicians.
- DanBC 7y agoIn the UK there is some oversight by the parliamentary committee and also the courts. Here's a case where the courts say that police surveillance was not correctly authorised: https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKIPTrib/2018/IPT_17_93_H.html https://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKIPTrib/2018/IPT_17_93_H.ht...
- GordonS 7y ago> Those apps that provide end-to-end encryption are a problem Are they though? There will always be a means to communicate without surveillance. Backdooring encryption is fundamentally incompatible with privacy, and will be abused - at scale. For any real cases, the security services have a multitude of other ways of getting the information they need regardless - for example, they could gaining physical access to the target's phone and backdoor/bug it, or swap it out with a backdoored/bugged one. The real problem with backdooring or outlawing encryption is that it lowers the bar to entry for governments - it makes it too easy, and such sweeping powers will be abused.
- mytailorisrich 7y ago> Backdooring encryption is fundamentally incompatible with privacy, That's a very bold claim. Lawful wiretapping exists because it is accepted (and reasonable) that privacy should stop in specific circumstances, e.g. a criminal investigation. As I wrote before seeing this in black or white is naive. Wiretapping is useful for society. The key is to have proper oversight. By the way, to lawfully wiretap a phone the authorities only need the phone number: The operator will then duplicate all traffic transparently and on the fly. Bugging a phone really means illegal/covert operations these days...
- ripdog 7y agoYou don't understand. Encryption is necessary because on the internet, there is no distance. Any web service today must be built with the knowledge that everyone, everywhere is attacking it all the time. The only defense against that kind of attack is an encryption that nobody can break. When a weakness is introduced into that defense, even if it's a secret key held only by trusted governments and only (they promise) to be used in emergencies, that key is a method of attack that anyone, anywhere can use against everyone. The only defense is that the secret key remain secret, and there are an endless number of ways it could be comprimised, ranging from human error, phishing, or plain old brute forcing. A single key for all Whatsapp conversations is a valuable enough prize for criminals all over the world to invest serious money in custom hardware to crack it. Currently, encryption schemes like Whatsapp's rely on generation of new keys for every message, making the value of attacking any one message limited. Without this defense, Whatsapp will be cracked, sooner or later. And once someone publicly reveals that key, every single message sent before that point becomes compromised. Maybe even publicly exposed. Would you be okay with that? Exposing your private message history to the internet because governments wanted to snoop?
- mytailorisrich 7y agoI do understand. This is an issue with Whatsapp's architecture, not with my comment or governments' concerns.
- jMyles 7y ago> Claiming that they should not be able to wiretap lawfully (or even otherwise) is a rather naive view of the world and lawful wiretapping does not imply dystopia. I hold the opposite view: that the idea that the evolutionary trajectory of the internet seems wont to continue to allow "wiretapping" (and, for that matter, the existence of a capricious state tout court) is the naive view. The state is looking increasingly obsolete every day, and moves like this are significant leaps forward in solidifying that conclusion.