4 ms·
The comment I'm referring to is the one saying we shouldn't grant rights because bad stuff happens to humans so we should solve those problems first. There are
by mellosouls 7y ago
The comment I'm referring to is the one saying we shouldn't grant rights because bad stuff happens to humans so we should solve those problems first. There are multiple replies to that, including mine, which I refer you to.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21100715 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21100715
- snagglegaggle 7y agoHmm... I think you are misreading his point. He seems to be pointing out that there are other things that are more important and that this seems to be a waste of time. Broadly I agree. One problematic reply I think is: >We should fix both immediate problems and the fundamental ethics issues that perpetuate an exploitative mindset. Animal rights are part of that. Until we have a really good test for animal intelligence and some tractable way to map that to utility I think this is seriously misguided. At the end of the day the wants of a human supersede the wants of an orangutan, even if only by force. Do I think there is much utility in how this orangutan was treated? Not really. But am I allowed to exploit the orangutan? Yes, to the same extent I have a right to life.