3 ms·
Be careful of what you ask for. IP laws are the foundation of what makes the GPL enforceable.
by kube-system 7y ago
Be careful of what you ask for. IP laws are the foundation of what makes the GPL enforceable.
- wind0w 7y agoWe need a 'right to repair' for software -- anyone release commercial software should be forced to release the source code and allow users to build, modify and distribute it for free.
- kazinator 7y agoFrom the perspective of a developer using the BSD license, such as myself, this isn't such a big deal. A violation means "someone removed or replaced the copyright notice in my source code file". I don't want them to stop using or redistributing the program, including in its binary form that has no copyright notices; just restore the notices in any redistributed source. I'm in favor of retaining only a limited form of IP law, which makes it unlawful to misrepresent the origin of a work. Basically, I would have academic misconduct and related types of misrepresentation continue to be offenses (even outside of an academic examination or publication setting), but not copying. Other than that, scrap copyright with extreme prejudice. Only problem is, what happens to the artists. Developers can still make money in a world in which the power of copyright is limited to fighting plagiarism. A lot of programs are in fact free to copy, but operate with limitations in the absence of a purchased license. But you can't record a song so that only limited features of the song are available for a limited time, unless the license is purchased. Such works can be taken outside of DRM easily via the analog hole.
- kube-system 7y agoWhich is why I used GPL as the example -- it requires modifications to be shared. BSD really wouldn't be affected nearly as much. If we lived in a world where all free software was more like BSD, projects would look a lot less like linux, and a lot more like this: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach_(kernel%29 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mach_(kernel%29
- randallsquared 7y ago> I'm in favor of retaining only a limited form of IP law, which makes it unlawful to misrepresent the origin of a work. There's a technical solution (crypto signing) to that which is applicable exactly to those people who care, so it seems unnecessary to have legal machinery to enforce it.
- breck 7y agoI think this is a very good point. With git and proof of work hash patterns, it becomes not only unwise to falsely try and take credit for someone else's work, but technically infeasible to do. It's also becomes quite easy to add references (did I forget something? -- send a pull request!).
- GlitchMr 7y agoYes, however if copyright did not exist, GPL would be unnecessary, all software would be free software. Sure, the source code sometimes wouldn't be available, but there would be nothing legally preventing decompilation. Sure, GPL software couldn't enforce releasing the source code, but for that matter, this is how it already works in European Union (as in EU, linking for purposes of interoperability is explicitly allowed).
- ryukafalz 7y ago>Sure, the source code sometimes wouldn't be available, but there would be nothing legally preventing decompilation. This is true but generally unhelpful. The result of decompilation often isn't nearly as readable as the original source, and at the very least you've lost all documentation. A world without copyright would look much closer to one with entirely permissively licensed software than one with entirely copyleft software.
- kube-system 7y agoUnfortunately, in a world without GPL, you might not have easy access to that binary. It could be installed on a piece of multi-million dollar enterprise hardware that you'd have to purchase to get one. That's probably exactly what companies like IBM would would do, if they weren't required to push their changes by GPL.
- GlitchMr 7y agoGPL doesn't prevent that unfortunately.
- kube-system 7y agoYes, it explicitly does. Even in version 1 this was addressed. See section 3a and 3b: https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-1.0.html https://www.gnu.org/licenses/old-licenses/gpl-1.0.html
- breck 7y agoGPL and copyleft are a clever hack to weaponize Intellectual Slavery laws against themselves, but a much simpler and better solution is just to work through Congress to repeal Intellectual Slavery laws of copyright and patents.
- kube-system 7y agoIf copyright didn't exist, nobody could be required to share their changes to another person's work under schemes like GPL. Corporations would no longer be legally compelled to contribute to free software projects. Projects like Linux would likely be abandoned as large institutional users fork the projects and leave the original project to rot.
- kazinator 7y agoIf copyright didn't exist, they could only use physical tamper-resistance techniques to protect their work from reverse engineering and copying.
- kube-system 7y agoOr they could simply refuse to sell it to you or anyone else without signing an NDA.