4 ms·
I upvoted you because in my heart I agree. Yet now having shipped commercial games my mind tells me otherwise. The simplest behaviour can cascade into bugs, edg
by Danieru 7y ago
I upvoted you because in my heart I agree. Yet now having shipped commercial games my mind tells me otherwise. The simplest behaviour can cascade into bugs, edge conditions, more feature requests, and for some features the base implementation is never the hard part.
Any feature which fundamentally transforms the final result, say by blocking a transaction, will be one of those cascading features. Sure just adding a "good enough to be 80% there" could be simple. Yet what happens when the client turns around and says "You delivered a broken app to me, I tried submitting my survey 3 times and only the first time was it accepted".
Sure this feature can be accommodated. The client might ask for special handling of test email accounts. Or an admin panel. Or a report & moderate workflow where they can override the block.
Getting to the core issue: the client did not see the value in the proposed work. If you are getting paid and spending extra time unpaid to give value to clients, you better be doing so because the client is going to be thankful.
Imagine a scenario where the OP ignored the clients wishes, implemented the feature anyway, tanked the negatives, all so that the client would not lose money to fraud, and thus prevent the client from seeing why the feature was needed in the first place. Lots of work, negative reward for the programmer.
- easytiger 7y ago> Getting to the core issue: the client did not see the value in the proposed work. The Op sounds like they were trying to graft more money from the client to me. The email was already stored. A trivial check would have reduced the triviality of the exploitation. Not to mention that multiple survey results from the same person cannot be assumed to be what the client wanted.
- QualityReboot 7y agoYour attitude is the difference between a junior developer and an experienced one.
- archi42 7y agoRemindes me of the lamentations of a friend working at a webdev company. Step 1: Their customer wants a "Don't send me e-mail" option for users of the system. Step 2: Customer goes into rage mode since an important users doesn't get some mails. Step 3: Do not to punch the customer in the face because that user had the "Don't send me e-mail" option set - and the customer could see that from their admin panel.
- z3t4 7y agoWhen you are new you should do exactly what the client says. When you are experienced you should get clients that are willing to pay extra for your experience.