12 ms·
Orangutan with Human Rights Begins New Life in Florida
- mellosouls 7y agoSpeaking as a layman and aware of the tendency to anthropomorphise, nevertheless: The time for animals of this cognitive and social level to be granted special protected rights and respect seems long overdue.
- ianai 7y agoAgreed. Look, the glaciers are disappearing, the Amazon rainforest has been lit on fire and almost eradicated by humans, and the climate radically altered. All because humans think they own the world and may do as they like with all of it, unilaterally. They don’t need to think about long term consequences because only their immediate needs matter. They don’t need to take any life into consideration other than themselves. They don’t even need to take humanity beyond their own person into account. It’s solipsism taken to a global, permanent scale because there are people who could unilaterally decide to end all life on earth as we know it through mass destruction. It’s time to open the blinders.
- lol2143651 7y agohttps://dailycaller.com/2019/06/07/national-park-glacier-warnings/ https://dailycaller.com/2019/06/07/national-park-glacier-war...
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Nasrudith 7y agoHuman level is just silly sophistry really even if though there should be some special protections for great apes such as minimal conditions, abolishing medical testing except for when they are outright patients to be aided, etc. If it were truly human level rights bestiality laws would be unconstitutional in that context for one. Orangutans would be allowed to vote (only age, citizenship, and possible felon status are valid qualifiers and not mental competency), and we would arrest orangutans for committing crimes against organutans and allow them to face their accusers in court. To be found incompetent to stand trial would require special casing for every last incident.
- mellosouls 7y agoI'm not advocating equivalent rights or status, and was careful not to phrase it that way.
- snagglegaggle 7y agoThis is definitely not as bad as the Saudi robot that is a person. Though despite the intelligence of nonhumans I am not sure I can support granting personage to things and property at this time. I think the Old Testament has interesting things to say on this topic: "Everything that creeps on the ground and all the fish of the sea are under your authority. " In a lot of ways Judaism and what it evolved into is the unreligion religion. Events in it, like the plagues of Egypt, are digs at the asinine nature of contemporary customs. E.g. the frogs were a plague because the frogs were sacred and could not be killed. In general the Abrahamic God doesn't want you fettering your wealth away on complicated rituals. In the West, you can usually see a split between people who view animals largely as property and those that don't. The latter concern me, because although I can oppose wanton cruelty -- when it comes down to it, there are people, and not people. And if I need to get rid of property because I can't maintain it, I should be able to do so.
- mellosouls 7y agoI'm unaware of the Saudi robot but as we are a long way off AI, that would be a thing with no inner life. This is a sentient creature, and - leaving aside the clear ethical questions that raises - considering our not always entirely inspirational stewardship of the planet and the creatures on it, I question your support for consigning it all to the cold classification of "property".
- snagglegaggle 7y agoIt is not intended to be cold. I still appreciate nature, enjoy the company of animals, and want to work towards conservation. But a line does need to be drawn and that is where I think it should be drawn. Giving not-people the privileges of people is a slippery slope and I think best reserved until we achieve a greater understanding of intelligence.
- mellosouls 7y agoThat's a fair argument - but I would counter that in the context of animals that behave in what appears to be clearly intelligent and social behaviour of a higher order, higher order rights should follow. They don't need to be the same level, just indicative of a special status.
- trevyn 7y agoIronically, said rights were granted by an Argentine court, so presumably do not apply in Florida.
- mkonecny 7y agoDefinition: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irony https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/irony
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- stebann 7y agoIronically?
- trevyn 7y agoincongruity between the actual result of a sequence of events and the normal or expected result Orangutan is granted rights, and as a result is moved to a jurisdiction where the rights do not apply.
- op00to 7y agoI wish my government wished peace for me, instead of endless anxiety, fear, and strife.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- seamyb88 7y agoAmerica cages innocent people who don't have certain pieces of paper. Families are broken up and children separated from Mothers. But yea, long overdue monkey rights.
- mellosouls 7y agoTwo wrongs don't make a right. If we were to follow your logic we'd never make any progress in any laws. But I suspect your lack of support for the rights in this case is not actually connected to the false equivalence you have drawn to undermine it.
- pavlov 7y agoWe should fix both immediate problems and the fundamental ethics issues that perpetuate an exploitative mindset. Animal rights are part of that.
- seamyb88 7y agoA monkey has human rights in a country where humans don't. If that doesn't annoy you, you are warped.
- allannienhuis 7y agoIt's possible for society to tackle more than one injustice/problem at a time. Choosing one thing to work on isn't at the direct cost of another. It's reasonable to say that the overall efforts towards things should be proportional to the amount and degree of injustice, but it's not useful to mock people who are concerned about a specific problem.
- ianai 7y agoInstead of countering my arguments you’ve attempted to use a logical fallacy to negate my point. Two things can be true because they’re independent or caused by similar preconditions. You’re not offering the contradiction you appear to be claiming. HN guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- danschumann 7y agoBut with his credit score he can't get a car...
- DangitBobby 7y agoNeither can a child
- elboru 7y agoAre they taking her with her consent? Did she decided to go to Florida? Deluding the meaning of what a person is or what is not doesn’t look like a good idea in the long run.
- linuxftw 7y agoPeople have decide many things have all new meanings in recent years. This statement you're making today might be constructed has hate-speech toward non-human people in the future.
- JetSpiegel 7y agoIANAL, but if this animal is legally a person, he was kidnapped, since there was no consent in being taken to Florida, as the grandparent mentioned. Or is this a person without the full breadth of human rights?
- linuxftw 7y ago> legally a person It's not enough to say 'legally a person,' you must say 'person' without any qualification whatsoever. > Or is this a person without the full breadth of human rights? Rights are for peoples or persons, not humans.
- dmix 7y ago> Florida's Center for Great Apes Sounds like a fun place to work
- LifeLiverTransp 7y agoNext he will work as a bibliothecarian in a university.
- subsaharancoder 7y agoBy determining that all animals are sentient beings, would putting a plough on a cow to farm a piece of land then be viewed as a form of indentured servitude, what about harvesting honey from beehives, spraying bug spray could be viewed as some form of genocide? Where is the line drawn?