3 ms·
Economist here! I missed the vizier training classes though. That's unfortunate -- being able to intentionally shape world events would really satisfy the ego.
by tomrod 7y ago
Economist here!
I missed the vizier training classes though. That's unfortunate -- being able to intentionally shape world events would really satisfy the ego. /s
Truth be told, there is a spectrum of political leanings among economists akin to the spectrum of political leanings among developers. We're not a superclass of reptilian ubermensch and uberfrauen able to worm our ways into the minds of the powerful.
Possibly the main missing point is that the book appears to be uninformed that there are many economic scholars researching inequality, race[1], feminism[2], environmentalism[3], and other progressive areas[4].
Really, there is a broad set of things considered "economics" and I encourage folks to check it out[5].
Remember that all models are wrong, but some are useful. The article's mention of Oi's work highlights this, but the book's takeaway is weird. Rather than a justifiable conclusion of "economists are learning the same as the rest of the world how to manage their leaky abstractions" the book instead treats the reader to FUD.
[1] http://www.columbia.edu/~bo2/bookflyer2015.pdf http://www.columbia.edu/~bo2/bookflyer2015.pdf
[2] http://www.feministeconomics.org/ http://www.feministeconomics.org/
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_economics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Environmental_economics
[4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_religion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_religion
[5] https://www.aeaweb.org/jel/guide/jel.php https://www.aeaweb.org/jel/guide/jel.php
- specialist 7y agoContrarian is probably referring to the Rasputin like celebrity pundit economists who are funded and promoted by undeclared vested interests. Like the realtors backing Friedman (or was it Hayek?) and those Freakonomics guys. I'm TOTALLY FINE with lobbying, patronage, sponsorship, and bias. More than fine. If its declared. But even "serious economists" like you have to admit there's personalities claiming expertise you know they lack. The whole Gell-Mann Amnesia thing. Those times someone on TV spews some nonsense that makes you want to kick a puppy in outrage.
- tomrod 7y agoAgreed, idiot-punditry is alive and well in all areas of specialized domain knowledge. Charlatans make me want to kick things in outrage as well.
- soVeryTired 7y ago> Remember that all models are wrong, but some are useful. I can't count the number of times I've heard that trotted out as a tired defense of bad modelling. All models are wrong: some are useful, some are dangerous. Are you sure you can distinguish between those categories? > Possibly the main missing point is that the book appears to be uninformed that there are many economic scholars researching inequality, race[1], feminism[2], environmentalism[3], and other progressive areas[4]. I don't think either the reviewer or the book itself are claiming that there are no economists that study those causes. It sounds like the book claims that postwar economists have enjoyed unaccountable policy influence, and their methodology has blinded them to certain consequences of their advice.
- tomrod 7y ago> Are you sure you can distinguish between those categories? Typically yes, through appropriate risk assessment. Cue "Antifragile" here.
- soVeryTired 7y agoSo what does "appropriate risk assessment" look like? Vary some parameters and add confidence bounds to your outputs? If you're building an economic model and they economy enters a regime that you haven't seen before in your data, your model calibration is going to crumble. So maybe good models can be distinguished from bad when predicated on the assumption that the near future looks like the past. But when that changes (i.e. when you need your models most) is when your models become least reliable.
- SantalBlush 7y agoIt's really not a question of how bad an economic model is, but whether there exists a better one we can use in its place. When people criticize (often rightly) economic models and point out their limitations, there is an implication that we should abandon them because they are so flawed. But this is wrong. It is not enough to avoid flawed models; we need something demonstrably better to replace them with, and this is where the critics tend to come up short. Suppose we get rid of economists and their models; then what do we use in their place to guide policy? Our intuition? No thanks. If someone has a superior theory of the economy, they must show it with logic and empirical observation. Until they do, we are stuck with our more flawed models.
- foxhop 7y agoThank you vey much for your comment. I agree with most of your thoughts and learned a lot from it. Specifically, the FUD part sort of worked on me a bit in retrospect. The book was likely written this way because it gets listened to and sells copies. That said just because there is a dash of spin doesn't mean it is any less true.