11 ms·
The growing confrontation between the West and China seems to me to boil down to a philosophical problem: - Should free markets/societies/cultural entities all
by keiferski 7y ago
The growing confrontation between the West and China seems to me to boil down to a philosophical problem:
- Should free markets/societies/cultural entities allow participation by all actors, even those which (in their own spaces) obviously don't play by the rules of the entered market/society/culture?
- Or, should entry into the entity be restricted to those that themselves (in their own space) follow the rules of the entered culture?
It seems to me that there are definite advantages and disadvantages to both approaches and it's probably something that game theorists have addressed. To use a convoluted, over-simplified metaphor of a playground:
- If we allow kids (that have different rules in their own playground) into our playground, we run the risk of their rules overcoming or having a negative effect on ours. We also enable them to play with us while having "bad" rules on their own playground - some of which might give them an (unfair) advantage over us on our own playground. However, we get the benefits of having more kids and toys to play with. And, maybe the kids will choose our rules (which we perceive as better) over their own.
- If we don't allow them into our playground, we have less kids and toys to play with. We also have no real direct influence on them - they can't see that our rules are better in person, and we can't threaten to kick them out of our playground if they aren't in it to begin with. However, we avoid the risk of having their rules overwhelm ours and we worry less about them having unfair advantages over us on our own playground.
- xxxpupugo 7y ago> The growing confrontation between the West and China seems to me to boil down to a philosophical problem It is not West VS China, it is mainly US VS China. EU and other Asian developed economies might disdain China ideologically, but I don't think they have the appetite to break the status quo this eagerly. And it is nothing philosophical about it. It is geopolitical, and it is human nature. What you are saying are just intellectual seasoning, it may be necessary to intrigue the audience, but not for action. China is a new world power that competes with US both militarily and economically. Post WWII, US had fought with Soviet/Japan on those fronts separately, but China looks like a combination of both, makes it even more threatening and hard to tolerate.
- factsaresacred 7y ago> but I don't think they have the appetite to break the status quo this eagerly. Mainly they don't have the strength to break the status quo. Plus they don't want to jeopardise access to such a large market. It's a Faustian bargain they're beginning to regret. China is going to rise, this cannot and should not be prevented. But allowing them to rise at your own country's expense is folly. America gets this.
- xxxpupugo 7y agoAlso US can weather itself the best if the status quo is broken, because it is currently on top. Other countries won't be so lucky. Trump's actions feel dramatic, but mainly on the magnitude and fast aggression. Something is due to happen and the world needs to adapt to that new normal.
- thawaway1837 7y agoTrumps actions seem dramatic because they are largely incoherent with no end goal in mind and based on his personal feelings. The US would have made far more progress against China if it had remained in the TPP.
- simion314 7y agoSo you change the rules in the middle of the game so you don't lose, sounds right if you are the arbiter too
- speedplane 7y ago> The growing confrontation between the West and China seems to me to boil down to a philosophical problem ... Should free markets/societies/cultural entities allow participation by all actors, even those which (in their own spaces) obviously don't play by the rules of the entered market/society culture? You're missing one of the major points: freedom. The issue is not just weighing the utilitarian pros/cons of allowing diversity of thought. In the U.S. (and generally the west), the ability to think and do what you want is valued as an important individual right that each person is entitled to, regardless of whether it's good or bad for society as whole.
- keiferski 7y agoI'm specifically talking about the issue of allowing non-agreeable actors into your own space, or in the case of this article, stock exchanges.
- speedplane 7y ago> I'm specifically talking about the issue of allowing non-agreeable actors into your own space Yes, I get that's the point, but it's consistent with my original point: the right to be disagreeable, whether an outsider or not, is an important freedom that's valued in the U.S., regardless of whether it's a net socioeconomic benefit or loss.
- scottlocklin 7y ago>the ability to think and do what you want is valued as an important individual right that each person is entitled to, regardless of whether it's good or bad for society as whole. At one point in life I'd have agreed with you. Now I can't agree with this at all. Usually the West wants very specific kinds of freedom; the kinds which are useful for social control. The first amendment may remain in the US as a sort of residual idea from classical liberalism, but it seems not too many people actually want this.
- speedplane 7y ago> The first amendment may remain in the US as a sort of residual idea from classical liberalism, but it seems not too many people actually want this. I'm not sure the first amendment was ever really popular - Nazi's marching down a Jewish neighborhood, hippies burning the American flag, John Adams defending British soldiers involved in the Boston Massacre - freedom is often very unpopular. Just because something is unpopular doesn't mean it's not sacred.
- RobertRoberts 7y agoI think that you should play by the rules of the playground. If you think its ok to try and change other peoples rules to suit yourself instead of adampting to the rules of the area you enter then you are simply a bully.
- mytailorisrich 7y agoThe West bulldozed its way through the whole world and imposed rules that benefit it. The issue here is much less cultural that you might think. China has been weak in the past couple of centuries and was thus on the receiving end. But as they grow stronger the rules will have to change to take them and their interests into account. This obviously does not mean that we should cave in to everything. It means that they should have an equal say in the rules. At the moment it's the US fighting China more than the West as a whole. It makes sense because it's US dominance that is under threat. The question is whether the US want to fight a losing battle or work constructively for the long term.
- asabjorn 7y agoLet us look at the facts from [1]: - China require companies to transfer all intellectual property to a venture owned 51% by Chinese before getting access to market - people running joint ventures like clockwork open competing companies cutting western partners out - China is a developed country that declare themselves as developing to skirt economic and environmental controls - China has state owned companies that compete with western companies that they regularly subsidize to beat competition Also on a softer end China is trying to spread its way of ruling their people to the west [2]. How long do you think you’d last under such a system before being “re-educated” like the Muslim Uighur or Confucian Falun Gong? [1] https://ustr.gov/sites/default/files/2018-USTR-Report-to-Congress-on-China%27s-WTO-Compliance.pdf https://ustr.gov/sites/default/files/2018-USTR-Report-to-Con... [2] Deceiving the Sky: Inside Communist China's Drive for Global Supremacy https://www.amazon.com/dp/1641770546/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_Da4JDb3QDWT78 https://www.amazon.com/dp/1641770546/ref=cm_sw_r_cp_api_i_Da...
- pas 7y agoEqual say is nice, but I want equal treatment too. (Both when it comes to trading [MFN rules], and when it comes to law, courts, administration. They are extremely far in both regards from healthy/sane.) All the amazing gain and growth given to us by the free market worths nothing if it fuels oppression, if it raises barriers to entry to markets, if it pushes the whole economy toward monopolies and monopsonies, toward fragile centralization, and toward worse lives for the participants. And no, it should be more cultural, not less. There are clever and efficient policy tools to manage healthy free markets. Allowing China, the US or anyone to make people forget/ignore these cultural foundations and all the achievements of good policy (as in political cooperation and economic competition; from the forming of the US itself from the individual original states to the contemporary EEA integration such as traditional/geographical origin protection and indication, Schengen border control union, emission quotas, common food and drug inspection standardization, etc.), just because some country is strong would be a folly of the greatest magnitude.
- input_sh 7y agoWhat other country from the West has a beef with China? This is purely US vs China. Leave the rest of us out of your own mess please.
- ng12 7y agoSo what's the message, the EU is only interested in combating oppression when there's no money on the table?
- greatpatton 7y agoYeah a little bit like the US, supporting Saudi Arabia whatever they do.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- efdee 7y agoAre we pretending that any of this has to do with combatting oppression?
- pas 7y agoSo.. just to be clear. Are you aware of the consequences of economic inequality? You know, the greatly inequal opportunities, the drastic bargaining power difference, etc. Do you think China is not going to exploit its economic power to achieve political goals? Are you aware of China's political goals? Do you agree with them? Just to name a few: censorship, take Taiwan, suppression of self-determination of minorities, gaining more territory in the East China Sea (island building) from its neighbors.
- input_sh 7y agoCounter-question: How exactly is the US combating oppression in China? Apart from ruining your own relationship with your 3rd biggest trade partner, that is.
- jakeogh 7y agoPeople catching a hint of the real power they have is an existential threat to traditional myth structures; not just China's.
- OscarCunningham 7y agoAlternative hypothesis: Trump is bullying China to make himself appear strong to US voters. He has no objective other than that.
- ulfw 7y agoIt's not the 'West'. It's US America. And to be even more precise: it's GOP-led US America.
- yogthos 7y agoPeople seem to forget the basic fact that markets are run by greedy psychopaths. And I don't mean this as a hyperbole. Capitalism directly selects for psychopathic behavior because it's a system of Darwinian competition. The system efficiently selects for this behavior. If you want to have capitalism then the only sane approach is heavy government regulation.
- the_resistence 7y agoThink Anti-Vaxxers