3 ms·
> When prostitution is legalised, the demand often outstrips the supply, leading to an increase in human trafficking. This line of reasoning makes very little
by dcolkitt 7y ago
> When prostitution is legalised, the demand often outstrips the supply, leading to an increase in human trafficking.
This line of reasoning makes very little sense to me. Let's just consider another profession. It's pretty undeniable the demand for skilled software engineers currently outstrips the supply. Especially for certain in-demand specialists.
Yet we don't see machine learning PhDs being kidnapped and enslaved to work in a dank basement tuning Netflix's recommendation algorithm for hours on end with Reed Hastings and his goons threatening to kill their families. The simpler solution is for Netflix to just pay enough money to attract qualified people for the job.
Every single other market in the world has a simple mechanism to deal with the scenario where demand outstrips supply. And that is simply to let prices rises to the point where the two reach equilibrium.
There's absolutely zero reason why the market for prostitution should be any different. To the extent that it isn't it's only because law enforcement either is incapable of or refuses to investigate the complaints of crimes committed against sex workers.
- Mathnerd314 7y agoThere are some really shady things going on with H1B's; maybe kidnapping isn't the right term, but the choice is between working pretty terrible conditions and getting deported. The simple supply/demand argument you see in economics class works in very few cases that feature in internet debates. It works well on eBay when you're selling a used iPhone, but not on labor, healthcare, or housing as those markets are all heavily regulated in comparison.