4 ms·
Reminds me of stories I hear about rarely anyone who is in an NGO that manages or tries to help refugees has been in a camp or a refugee in their past, and when
by novok 7y ago
Reminds me of stories I hear about rarely anyone who is in an NGO that manages or tries to help refugees has been in a camp or a refugee in their past, and when they actually get into those organizations, see how out of touch they are.
Ex:
" I went to endless meetings on refugee shelter and nobody ever invited a single refugee. I only ever saw one refugee at a meeting about refugee shelter, it was a doctor from Canada who had grown up in a refugee camp in Africa. She had become quite a senior doctor and when she came in it was like an axe murder. She was unbelievably angry, and she literally just called out every single thing the speaker said that wasn’t true."
"the boss lady from UNHCR (United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees) come around to inspect the shelters refuse to set foot inside of it. She was fucking furious that one had been built there. The fear that they had was the the Hexayurts were too cheap and they lasted too long. They were afraid that what was going to happen was that every place that they built them the locals were going to look at them and say That’s actually pretty good, and start building them themselves. And I’m just like, Does that not solve the fucking problem? Is that not what we want—local resilience? The more you find out about how these systems run the worse the expectation gets. It’s very messy. "
https://www.yesplz.coffee/vinay_gupta_hexayurt_interview/ https://www.yesplz.coffee/vinay_gupta_hexayurt_interview/
- michaelt 7y agoAbout 20 years ago I worked on a project designing pop-up shelter buildings, and that's a misrepresentation of UNHCR policy. Their policy is both simple and logical once you know it: The main challenge with refugee camps is not an engineering issue; the challenge is getting nearby countries to agree to host camps. Countries will agree much more easily to host a temporary camp - which means it has to visibly be a temporary camp. It turns out, once you know about this constraint (and the obvious facts about cost, logistics, and that camps have large amounts of manual labour available) it's extremely difficult to improve on 10,000 year old canvas tent technology.