4 ms·
In which countries does capitalistic healthcare work well? Or do you mean just within your theory it works well and that there are none that actually do it?
by cma 7y ago
In which countries does capitalistic healthcare work well? Or do you mean just within your theory it works well and that there are none that actually do it?
- woofyman 7y agoPlastic surgery is capitalistic healthcare.
- elliekelly 7y agoThe incentives are very different. When the doctor says injections or implants will set you back $X it's not a matter of life and death. Or even health at all. You can choose to wait and save up. When the doctor says you need medical treatment that costs $X you're going to have to come up with a way to get the money even if you go broke trying. And that's assuming you're lucky/healthy enough to even be given a chance to price shop. It's hard to go broke getting boob jobs. It's exceedingly easy (in US) to go broke getting even the most basic of health care.
- woofyman 7y agoGood points. When I was taken by ambulance to an out of network trauma center, I had no choice.
- Causality1 7y agoIt worked well in the US until around 1990.
- ros65536 7y agoSwitzerland and a few other countries have fully privatized medicine. You don't hear about them dying from preventable diseases.
- neaden 7y agoPrivatised medicine is not a free market, conflating them like this is disengenuous.
- scarejunba 7y agoThe system in India works for the middle-class and upper. They have fairly elastic supply of doctors so it balances out. Some of their surgical outcomes have higher performance than American surgeries, particularly some heart surgeries. Cheaper, faster, better.
- surfmike 7y agoSwitzerland. Netherlands. In one ranking they are the best systems in Europe.
- shantly 7y agoDo any of them not have price controls and a “public option” of some sort? And sometimes prohibition on for-profit insurance (Switzerland, for example, IIRC)?
- surfmike 7y agoNo public option from what I know. Insurance is all private, Swiss require no profits while Netherlands allows for profit. Government subsidies and restrictions exist on the plans, similar to Obamacare.
- davidgay 7y agoSwitzerland has compulsory healthcare, insurance subsidies for low-income people, extremely heavy regulation of health insurance companies, and many (mostly?) public hospitals. Not exactly something I'd describe as "capitalistic health care".
- surfmike 7y ago40% of hospitals in Switzerland are private vs 69% in the US (21% for-profit). Most hospitals in Netherlands are private (non-profit). Both have all private insurance, although Switzerland requires it to be non-profit. Obamacare subsidizes and regulates insurance in the ways you stated, but could be made stronger. Perhaps not pure capitalistic healthcare, but a strong role for the private sector.
- cma 7y agoNetherlands has a mandate, universal healthcare, and free coverage for children up to 18, not capitalistic. And: >Affordability is guaranteed through a system of income-related allowances and individual and employer-paid income-related premiums. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_the_Netherlands#Finance https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Healthcare_in_the_Netherlands#...