4 ms·
Your argument of self-regulation and lack of government intervention is pretty well undermined by the current situation of hundreds sick and a dozen deaths in a
by ineedasername 7y ago
Your argument of self-regulation and lack of government intervention is pretty well undermined by the current situation of hundreds sick and a dozen deaths in a period of months. Sure, the market may correct, but the damage done before that isn't fixed.
As for things like neem oil etc., perhaps the current regulations are insufficient, doesn't mean they should be done away with all together.
Also, regulation doesn't automatically stop market competition: If the market has corrected the use of pesticides in the past, there's no reason competitors couldn't do so again through market forces above & beyond what the regulations require. Heck, it happens all of the time. The FDA has minimum guidelines for meat grading, but there's plenty of competition on quality, e.g., Angus beef, that is far above the minimum grades required for human consumption.
Regulation sets a baseline minimum, not a maximum, and there's an endless number of items that compete on quality much higher than the baseline.
- whatshisface 7y ago>Sure, the market may correct, but the damage done before that isn't fixed. To be fair, it's not like regulation can cure those people either.
- ineedasername 7y agoNo, it could prevent future incidents. The market can only respond to them. Proactive vs. reactive.
- whatshisface 7y agoRight, but so could a market self-correction. They're both delayed remedies.
- ineedasername 7y agoMarket correction doesn't solve future issues, just the specific one at hand. Regulation sets a baseline so that problems below that baseline of quality are much less likely to crop up.
- whatshisface 7y agoYou can't regulate against scams that haven't been anticipated yet any more than the market can correct for them. Both democratic regulations and market correction depend on the same thing, which is the population's awareness of a problem, so one can't possibly be more vigilant than the other.
- ineedasername 7y agogreat, so lets use both: regulation to set the baseline, markets to take care of issues that arise above or outside of that baseline.
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- OGWhales 7y agoBut which one is more consistent? Are you gonna trust wide spread laws and regulations or that high school kid selling carts out of his Honda Element to be more reliable when it comes to safety checking?
- ben509 7y ago> Your argument of self-regulation and lack of government intervention is pretty well undermined by the current situation of hundreds sick and a dozen deaths in a period of months. No, this is a black market that exists because of the government prohibiting the legal market. And the black market does a shit job of correcting these problems because it lacks the transparency of the legal market. For instance, it's extremely difficult to determine the reputation of sellers who have to hide their identity. Let's also keep in mind government intervention can be actively dangerous if they think they're protecting people from themselves. Back during prohibition, for instance, they poisoned 10,000 people[1] to try and scare them into not drinking. > Sure, the market may correct, but the damage done before that isn't fixed. No one can see into the future. We didn't know the war on drugs would cause all the problems it did. We saw a serious problem getting worse and identified the behavior that seemed to be causing problems and then made those actions illegal. And we already have the government involved in markets when it decides civil cases. The best case for regulation is when you have people suing each other for damages and the government, which has to rule on these cases anyway, passes a law that simply enforces the outcome of many similar judgements. [1]: https://vinepair.com/articles/government-prohibition-poison-alcohol/ https://vinepair.com/articles/government-prohibition-poison-...