2 ms·
I think that argument "proves too much", as the saying goes. Something wildly unlikely can always happen that turns your good intentioned idea into a genocidal
by BurningFrog 7y ago
I think that argument "proves too much", as the saying goes.
Something wildly unlikely can always happen that turns your good intentioned idea into a genocidal nightmare or other disaster.
So an honest application of this principle would result in never doing anything. That would of course be impossible.
But usually proponents only apply this "you never know what might go wrong!" kind of thinking for things they already dislike.
So in practice it boils down to "we shouldn't do things I have a bad feeling about, because you never know etc". And that is possible to argue for!
In reality, there are always risks, and you have to weigh them realistically against the reward, and accept that occasionally things go bad.
- kragen 7y agoPolice and prosecutors abusing their power is not "wildly unlikely"; it happens every day. The government of a country being replaced by one with newly terrible human rights policies that go far beyond the usual abuses isn't "wildly unlikely" either; it typically happens in several countries every year. In the last five years it's happened in Yemen, parts of Iraq and Syria, Venezuela, Brazil, Turkey, China, Crimea, and Hungary, and, according to many human rights organizations, the United States of America.