4 ms·
I love those articles, and the lesson learned from them. But there is no automatic parallel in this situation, in fact the opposite here. The NTSB isn’t suggest
by dahart 7y ago
I love those articles, and the lesson learned from them. But there is no automatic parallel in this situation, in fact the opposite here. The NTSB isn’t suggesting that Boeing model a single “average” pilot. They’re suggesting that Boeing test using many pilots who are not highly trained in test procedures. The “flaw of averages” problem is one of combining averages in multiple dimensions and assuming the result is still average. That flaw is absent when you test with multiple average people and categorize the results for each dimension separately.
Also, the outcome of the flaw of averages was to make various parts of the plane adjustable. In the case of an air emergency, your response time is not adjustable, you either solve it or you die. The NTSB’s suggestion is to understand how normal people react to ensure both ergonomics and training are adequate.
In any case, recommending that testing be done with people less knowledgeable than the experts, who don’t instantly know the right answers, can likely only result in better outcomes, not worse.
- alexis_fr 7y agoI like the idea that they pick pilots at random: - Either it’s Boeing’s fault for improper UX, - Either it’s Boeing’s fault for pilot certifications not being stringent enough. In either case, the aircraft manufacturer must improve. I think of it as an “integration test”, “let’s see how the pilot+plane integrate together”. Not necessarily Boeing, btw. It could be Airbus. It could even be a move from the US regulator which advantages Boeing compared to Airbus depending on whether Airbus planes were tested with skilled pilots.
- mlyle 7y agoIt's always fun to look at the performance figures in aircraft manuals. Somewhere, a skilled test pilot got those numbers in a pristine plane. But mere humans in a real-world plane will typically not obtain them.