3 ms·
This problem would be resolved if type certifications expired. Eg. A newly certified plane type can be produced for 15 years before requiring recertification
by londons_explore 7y ago
This problem would be resolved if type certifications expired.
Eg. A newly certified plane type can be produced for 15 years before requiring recertification to new standards.
In effect, this forces Boeing to come up with new designs, since the chances of old designs meeting new standards are low. It'll give them a big incentive to find ways to get the cost of certifications down.
Up to them if they choose to evolve the plane with the standards, or do a ground-up redesign every 15 years.
- ceejayoz 7y agoNew designs tend to have new issues. The pre-MAX 737s tend to be remarkably safe because the inherent mechanical issues have been detected and fixed over billions of flight hours.
- mannykannot 7y ago> It'll give them a big incentive to find ways to get the cost of certifications down. That is exactly what went wrong in the 737 MAX process -- the goal was achived by using political pressure to weaken the oversight. With proper oversight, type-certificate extension is a sound process. Without it, no form of certification is effective.
- sokoloff 7y agoThat's an interesting proposal. Thanks for bringing it forward. It would certainly increase costs in the industry and might introduce discontinuities in the pilot supply, particularly during irregular ops (weather delays causing crew timeouts causing crew substitutions) when pilots of 2015-era narrowbody jet #7 can't fly the 2014-era narrowbody jet #7 because the type rating is different or we have to stuff into their brains the qualifications for both the pre- and post- and have them alternate recurrent training between the two types, which brings its own safety concerns as compared to sending the crew to only one type of recurrent every required period. Alternatively, we might address that by giving a common type rating to the aircraft (such as with the 757 and 767, which share a common type rating [the pilot qualification basis] today despite being built on different type certificates [the aircraft certification basis]), which would allow for common recurrent training with just differences training across models/series.