2 ms·
This (latest) RMS incident is the confluence of The Structure of Presidential Scandals and Outrage Culture. The personal, character failings of public figures
by specialist 7y ago
This (latest) RMS incident is the confluence of The Structure of Presidential Scandals and Outrage Culture.
The personal, character failings of public figures are tolerated until they run out of goodwill. Then a "scandal" occurs. Nothing new is actually discovered. We always knew about President Clinton's extra marital stuff. It just didn't matter, until it did.
I don't have anything useful to add about Outrage Culture. Along with everyone else, I'm still trying to figure it out. Closest analogy I can think of is candidate Gary Hart put his head in the lion's mouth one too many times.
--
My take on RMS is a little bit, um, unconventional. Having never met him, I imagine he's somewhere between neurotypical and an ultimatist and a square peg in a world of round holes. His pedantry regarding Minsky wasn't wrong, exactly. It was just unwittingly in bad taste. A common recurrence for RMS.
Unfortunately for RMS, this time it mattered. Per the bit about scandals above; public opinion towards RMS crossed some unmarked tipping point, and he doesn't have enough allies to help save his public image.
RMS will be fine.
And I'm actually okay with this kind of court of public opinion. I want our public figures to keep pace with the times, to adapt, to remain effective & relevant. If RMS can't or won't, then it's his time to sit down, and let someone more palatable serve as arrow catcher for a while (the job of the ultimatist).
- yourbandsucks 7y agoFWIW, there's some decent evidence that the Hart 'Monkey Business' thing was a set-up: https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/11/was-gary-hart-set-up/570802/ https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2018/11/was-gar...
- concordDance 7y agoIf your dead friend gets accused of something in a wrong/misleading fassion it is in bad taste to defend them? > I want our public figures to keep pace with the times, to adapt, to remain effective & relevant No you really don't want your public figures to try and optimize for things that result in good public opinion, though outlining my reasoning for this would probably be around 2000 words, so not doable on a phone. (I started writing, then realized how big a topic that is)
- specialist 7y agoPlay in the mud, you're gonna get dirty. RMS could have demanded an investigation. Wait for the firestorm to subside. "you really don't want your public figures to try and optimize for things that result in good public opinion" Ya. I really do. Progress marches on, social norms adapt. Despite the recurring inevitable oversteer, currently manifesting as outrage culture, no way I want to go back in time.
- specialist 7y agoMea culpa. I imagined RMS to be an oblivious geek who can't seem to STFU. I was wrong. I regret the error. My only excuse is that I really didn't want RMS to be a bad guy, like ESR. Be wary of heroes. They'll disappoint you.