4 ms·
The OpenBSD IPsec-Stuxnet connection
- Confusion 16y agoThis guy sure seems to have a talent for coincidences With a limited number of people and places involved in a scene, such 'coincidences' are inevitable. It'd be more surprising if no such connection could be found. Any evidence is lacking.
- bootload 16y ago"... meanwhile in calgary... wasting no time netsec was secretly funnelling "security fixes" through mr.t that he was committing "stealth" into openbsd tree. (this i only knew years later when i was telling mr.t over a beer about the funny people i met on a west-coast trip (see later)). "stealth" means that purpose of the diffs was not disclosed in the commit messages or the private openbsd development forums except with a few "trusted" developers. ..." ~ http://mickey.lucifier.net/b4ckd00r.html http://mickey.lucifier.net/b4ckd00r.html what you say is understandable, but there appeared to be a lot of subterfuge going on.
- nl 16y agoI hope the author of this post thought pretty carefully about posting that. There have already been a number of people associated with Stuxnet and/or the Iranian nuclear program who have gone missing/died from strange accidents/been assassinated. [1][2] In simple terms, claiming someone possibly wrote Stuxnet puts their life in danger. [1] http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/12/06/iran_claims_stuxnet_expert_hit_squad_arrests/ http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/12/06/iran_claims_stuxnet_... [2] http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20101129/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iran_nuclear http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20101129/ap_on_re_mi_ea/iran_nucl...
- borism 16y agoWhile probably somewhat true, I don't see how your links prove that being associated with Stuxnet development puts ones life at risk. Both are talking about iranian nuclear scientists being killed!
- tptacek 16y ago"Associated with Stuxnet" and "associated with the Iranian nuclear program" are two extremely different things.
- marshray 16y agoI hope the author of this post thought pretty carefully about posting that Keep in mind, the NYT is publishing a four page Sunday article here and serving up the INL slideshow document with all these names in it. I am simply pointing out the connection to the other weird scandal of the year, the OpenBSD thing. I doubt "and you backdoored our VPN too!" is going to be the thing to push the Iranians over the edge.
- hackermom 16y agoThis blog entry was just an unnecessarily inflammatory excuse for "journalism". Why?!
- tptacek 16y agoContent, please?
- hackermom 16y agoElaborate.
- tptacek 16y agoSure: you didn't say anything in your comment. You intimated that Marsh Ray was perpetrating a false and puffed-up attempt at (your scare-quotes) "journalism". You ought to have supported that argument with evidence. For what it's worth: if you're following the story closely enough to have an educated opinion about it, the name "Marsh Ray" means something to you.
- hackermom 16y agoI'm sorry, I didn't know that I had to :) But, alright, for one, I think it serves no use other than bringing false attention to the topic when introducing the Stuxnet/SCADA angle in the discussion. There's no juicy coincidence of any kind to take note of. "Coincidence? I think not!".
- marshray 16y agoBaloney! I never claimed it was "journalism", merely a blog post written at 2 AM pointing out an interesting connection I came across.
- hjkldfger 16y ago====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== Gold autumn, personality Mes clothing + Shoes, Travel bag that grabs an eye coat + Chao packet Free transport ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )==== ====== ( http://u.ly/73I http://u.ly/73I )====
- tptacek 16y agoCome on, Marsh. How many people at INL have worked on SCADA security research? There's a lot of them. Furthermore, your premise is incoherent. There hasn't been a backdoor identified in OpenBSD IPSEC. The "bugs" that have been found (scare-quotes because all of them had been fixed already) weren't usable as backdoors. Were commits to IPSEC laundered via Canada? Yes. The reason? Because Theo believed that a US commit tainting the IPSEC source code could subject IPSEC to US export controls. What's the "coincidence" you think you've found?
- motters 16y agoSCADA isn't exactly mainstream technology. It's used primarily in factories. Having worked in industrial automation areas for quite a while I'd estimate that the number of people doing security testing on Siemens PLCs is a very small community.
- tptacek 16y agoIt is very much a mainstream software security research topic.
- marshray 16y agoI'd estimate that the number of people doing security testing on Siemens PLCs is a very small community Right, and how big was it in 2008? And how many of them do you suppose were also committing to OpenBSD's network stack in 2000-2001?
- tptacek 16y agoIt was big in 2008, Marsh. We're not a SCADA specialty firm, and we ended up doing SCADA-related work in 2008, and in 2007, and in 2006. One of my BigCo enterprise clients hired a network security guy --- network security, not software --- from a pure-play SCADA software security consultancy.
- marshray 16y agoThat's interesting. I'm not sure exactly how critical the absolute size of SCADA security in 2006 is in the question of evaluating the magnitude of the coincidence. It almost seems like something @alexhutton's could plug into one of his Bayesian models.
- pyre 16y agoI love how he uses recent example of US citizens being hassled at the border to imply that it happened well into the past (a time when the borders were a lot more open).
- marshray 16y agoYes, it's not a perfect comparison since he (along with many other OpenBSD devs from the time) wasn't a US citizen, but read the document from Mickey.