5 ms·
If there was a credible risk of "increased risk of systemic government oppression", I might agree with you. So far I haven't heard any remotely convincing argu
by BurningFrog 7y ago
If there was a credible risk of "increased risk of systemic government oppression", I might agree with you.
So far I haven't heard any remotely convincing argument.
- romaaeterna 7y agoYes. Someone needs to flesh out a candidate sort of government oppression that could be stopped by this sort of law. I think the opposite -- inaccurate police work is an oppression all its own, leads to the incarceration of the innocent, and that more and better DNA testing is a great thing.
- mlyle 7y agoIt's one thing when the better police work is purely being used to catch murderers and rapists. When it moves down the ladder to omniscience about citizen activities in general, it gets scarier. No one doubts that license plate camera databases of citizen movements, Stringray devices, etc, can help solve a whole bunch of crimes. But they can also be used to crush civil liberties in the hands of an authoritarian state. They can also be used for petty abuses of power. So it is with this, of being able to attribute any genetic information left behind to the particular person it's from. We have a whole lot of laws, and almost everyone breaks some every day. Very efficient law enforcement able to "solve these crimes" easily can be wielded against anyone.
- oh_sigh 7y agoYes, clearly when you develop nightmare scenarios, they are scary. The point is is there any reason to believe those nightmare scenarios have any realistic chance of coming true?
- RaceWon 7y ago> The point is is there any reason to believe those nightmare scenarios have any realistic chance of coming true Let's look at Trump. Like or loathe him, reasonable people will agree if there was a skeleton or three in his past it would be used to attempt to unseat him. He, however, lived most his life before tech existed. So what will happen to a President 50 years from now? I'm not knocking Monks here--but who among us has emulated their legendary behavior throughout their entire lives? So I for one do believe those nightmare scenarios will come true.
- mlyle 7y agoSure. We saw Hoover, Nixon, and others in the past use FBI and IRS records to harass opposition figures. We've seen some current police departments retaliate against citizens who have made internal affairs complaints and other critics in various ways. It's part of our past, and part of our present to some degree. Not to mention what we see happening in some other places in the world. Why would we not believe abuses would be part of our future, especially if they become easier?
- BurningFrog 7y agoHobbyists are already making license plate readers to monitor the traffic around them, for fun and security. The tech is so simple and cheap that this surveillance will be part of life whether the state participates or not.
- ArnoVW 7y agoThe example I always give: in the Netherlands in the 30's there was a census. Everyone gently filled in the number of people in their family, their ages, and their religion. Because, surely there was no harm in helping the state better organise the country? Unfortunately the Germans found those same records very useful a couple of years later, and they tracked down the families that had filled in "jewish" as religion. In France such a central register did not exist, for cultural and political reasons. Even today the French state state has explicitly chosen not to keep per-race statistics on crime etc. WW II stats: ------------ Jews dead in France: 25% Jews dead in the Netherlands : 95% Just because you trust your current government, and because you are currently not a minority, does not mean that you run the what-ifs.
- Zenst 7y agoA most excellent example that highlights what should and should not be captured and stored. Though sadly even today we have forms from doctors/governments that ask for race (I always out of principle scrub that out and write "human"). But then they say these metrics are captured to help prevent discrimination kinda argument! As your wonderful example shows, that can be abused. Really gets down to DNA being useful and abusable in many ways. The real onus should as always with such personal data - be in the hands of the individual and with that, the ability to opt-in/out choice needs to be there. I'd have no problem of my DNA to be used to help identify a crime perpetrated by some genetic relative, some on the other hand would not. But the choice should be with the individual and a complete ban, removes that right from those who would want to aid justice. When things can be used for good and bad, blanket bans do not work out as well and it should be down to a default position of no, but the ability for individuals to opt-in.
- BurningFrog 7y agoI think that argument "proves too much", as the saying goes. Something wildly unlikely can always happen that turns your good intentioned idea into a genocidal nightmare or other disaster. So an honest application of this principle would result in never doing anything. That would of course be impossible. But usually proponents only apply this "you never know what might go wrong!" kind of thinking for things they already dislike. So in practice it boils down to "we shouldn't do things I have a bad feeling about, because you never know etc". And that is possible to argue for! In reality, there are always risks, and you have to weigh them realistically against the reward, and accept that occasionally things go bad.