5 ms·
Raising capital isn't success. Profitability is success. I think the main value of Gatsby is the community-generated recipes to plug and play...but is there va
by hogFeast 7y ago
Raising capital isn't success. Profitability is success.
I think the main value of Gatsby is the community-generated recipes to plug and play...but is there value here?
If you have one very generic application, then maybe you save time upfront. But you are tied into this heavy wrapper around React that will probably cause you problems down the line. And you probably still need a backend. So I am not sure what value is being created?
If you specifically need to generate lots of sites, or you have some performance requirement (and data that doesn't change often) then maybe. But I wouldn't use it to build anything complex (i.e. that would tie me into their product) because building an app isn't that much harder. I am sure there is a niche use but I think most people aren't doing anything complicated with it (I use it that way).
I also don't really see how this could be a Wordpress killer (which is the intent of the fundraising presumably). Wordpress is totally end-to-end, it abstracts away all the right parts. This doesn't. $15m won't change that.
In theory, I think applications like Prismic or Contentful (I think it is) actually break up these tasks better. From your app, you have a (usually) simple API. And it reflects the division of labour in most companies i.e. that code and content are separate (before anyone says it: they aren't offering a different product to Gatsby, if it seems that way then that is the point).
- graphememes 7y agoIt doesn't look like Gatsby itself is what is the main selling point, and I'd argue, the VC doesn't think Gatsby itself is either. Gatsby Preview / Gatsby Content Mesh is most likely the horse being bet on.
- subpixel 7y ago> Raising capital isn't success. Profitability is success. Automattic just raised $300 million dollars a week or so ago. One vision of success, I'm very sure, is getting acquired by Automattic.