2 ms·
I do agree that broad relative estimates for different paths can be useful once the project is underway, and in fact said so. But I just don't believe that the
by wpietri 7y ago
I do agree that broad relative estimates for different paths can be useful once the project is underway, and in fact said so.
But I just don't believe that the high-level decisions you describe can be effectively estimated in calendar terms. Even if you get the execs to cough up sufficient details for real estimates (which they won't), those decisions are being made at the point in the project lifecycle when people know the very least. Any user-focused team will learn a ton along the way that shapes the product, and presumably neither the competition nor the market is standing still. Better decisions driven by learning means scope volatility, which means there's a hard limit on the utility of estimates.
I think the best one can do on day 0 is give reasonable sanity checks and the haziest of ballpark numbers. But that's fine, because execs are making ROI calculations, and there's no point to making your I more precise than your R. And we all know how much of a SWAG business value estimates are early on.