4 ms·
This is a smart move by China. There are a lot of reasons to do big science projects other than accomplishing the science itself. One of the biggest is that you
by godelski 7y ago
This is a smart move by China. There are a lot of reasons to do big science projects other than accomplishing the science itself. One of the biggest is that you get a lot of the smartest minds around the world in the same place as one another. The country that is hosting them will receive more benefits than the other countries participating (though everyone wins in some way). You also are more likely to get the spinoffs that always come off from working on difficult projects.
China is also building a super collider that's larger than CERN. The big question though is if they plan on doing an international effort (and if so, can they attract international scientists while operating an authoritarian state?) or if they plan on doing it only nationally (seems much harder to do and not as effective).
- SiempreViernes 7y agoThey have loose plans for building one, there is no current construction, or indeed even a definitive descision. Even when the chinese decide is uncertain: could be next year, could be in three years(1). The only thing that exists is a conceptual design, that isn’t even sited! (1): https://indico.ihep.ac.cn/event/9832/session/0/contribution/49/material/slides/0.pdf https://indico.ihep.ac.cn/event/9832/session/0/contribution/...
- tempguy9999 7y ago> There are a lot of reasons to do big science projects other than accomplishing the science itself One is national prestige. I'm not sure that's a good reason (if that's what's happened here).
- godelski 7y agoI think it definitely does help. National pride is definitely a factor that matters. You can say that your country is on the forefront of science. Personally I'm very happy to spend a lot of money on science. It helps push humanity forward and is good for the economy (ROI is high in the long run, though maybe not in the short term. Which is why government funding is better than commercial)
- tempguy9999 7y agoAt the risk of misrepresenting chinese efforts, my point was a bigger scientific instrument might just be willy waving. Blowing resources doesn't necessarily get results. If someone claims a new supercomputer place, the first thing to ask is whether they're getting real performance out of it. (I'll repeat that this a question, and not an assertion that china's making a mistake)
- godelski 7y agoOh I think I misunderstood what you were saying. > Blowing resources doesn't necessarily get results. > If someone claims a new supercomputer place, the first thing to ask is whether they're getting real performance out of it. So like TaihuLight[0] and Tianhe[1]? ([2]) I still think these machines add to national pride, but you're right that the money would be much better spent if it ALSO did actual science. I don't think these kinds of moves are as beneficial, because the benefits that I described in my first post are well known in the community (though not sure if they are well known by the public or even Rick Perry (though I know he's been told)). [0] https://top500.org/system/178764 https://top500.org/system/178764 [1] https://top500.org/system/177999 https://top500.org/system/177999 [2] I work on super computers and from my understanding (I haven't personally used Taihu or Tianhe) is that these computers are "Linpack machines" (linpack is the metric used to quantify the rankings). That these computers are extremely difficult to work with (all super computers are difficult to work with, and so these are HPC guys telling me that they don't want to work with those machines and are much happier to work on machines like Summit, Sierra, or even Titan) and so not much science is actually done on them.
- tempguy9999 7y agoWhoa, you work in HPC? Wow. I understood that the TaihuLight etc. were based on SW26010 cpus and as these use scratchpad rather than automatic cache hierarchies I assumed they were a bugger to program therefore were less efficient (it's not that simple but you know what I mean). But I checked on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOP500#TOP_500 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TOP500#TOP_500 which gave, for this machine, Rpeak (theoretical peak) of 125 PFlops[0] and Rmax ("the highest score measured using the LINPACK benchmarks suite") as 93 PFlops. Which really wasn't at all bad compared to the US machines, so I wondered where that left my assumptions. But you now mention they're hard to use. I'd assumed that if linpack was written and tested, you just used it and got the peformance. Apparently not? (I don't work with supercomputers, just in case you hadn't noticed)
- kayaeb 7y agoFAST is actually having difficulty hiring (on-site specialists like operations director) the smartest minds because it's in a jungle in small-town China. But yes, overall China is executing an excellent "brain drain" (not meant in a negative sense) by being willing to invest in these "keystone" projects when other countries are tightening budgets.
- godelski 7y agoTelescopes generally have this problem though. Because it sucks to live out in the middle of nowhere and you typically want to bring your family (which means you need cities to support things like schools and recreation. Most labs/research sites I know are like this. China Lake is an exception. But even Groom Lake has has Vegas near it).