4 ms·
> Fast Company has compiled a list of the most innovative companies, charging applicants fees between $495 and $1,000 to be considered. I find this pretty dist
by gnicholas 7y ago
> Fast Company has compiled a list of the most innovative companies, charging applicants fees between $495 and $1,000 to be considered.
I find this pretty distasteful, at least in the startup context. They’ve repeatedly approached me (after covering my startups) to apply. I’ve asked them if we can have the fee waived since they’ve essentially pre-vetted us, but no dice.
It might make sense to suck it up and pay them since we probably have a decent shot of getting selected, but I’ll never do it.
- syedkarim 7y agoIs there a tangible value to being on that list?
- gnicholas 7y agoI would guess there are two possible benefits: 1: publicity from being on the list, which FastCo presumably promotes at least once during the year (and probably leave up during the year) 2: being able to say you were selected for FastCo's list, which presumably gives you cred among certain groups. I do wonder if you might be held in lower regard by people who are aware that the competition costs so much just to enter.
- JohnJamesRambo 7y agoI for one will never forget what it means now that I know they paid a bribe to be on it.
- ansible 7y agoIt is bribery, yes. It doesn't seem too expensive as far as marketing costs go.
- gnicholas 7y agoI would actually be interested to know what percent of companies that pay to enter are included on one of the lists. If a large percentage of companies are honored, then it seems like a pretty transparent pay-to-play. This means the list is pretty worthless. OTOH, if a small percentage of companies are honored, then that means lots of companies are paying non-trivial fees and getting nothing in return. I believe the money is used to pay the people who review the applications, but unless those people have to be paid hundreds of dollars per application, or unless they have a high degree of redundancy in application review, the application fees wouldn't make sense. Basically, it would mean the list is a money-maker for them because they're accepting fees from so many unqualified companies. Either way (pay-to-play or revenue source), it definitely leaves a bad taste in my mouth. Frankly, it'd be cool if they offered a way to crowdsource the selection process, where each company that applied was given 10 companies to rank. As long as the 10 given to each person were randomly selected, it would be difficult/impossible to game the system and upvote friends. Also, companies could be given applications from other lists (I think there's a social-impact list and a general-purpose innovation list) to make sure there are no conflicts.
- justinclift 7y agoEgo stroking for those people that desire it?
- ian0 7y agoThere is a bunch of free programs for startups too, global competitions that fly some startups to a nice destination to pitch. I get the feeling the main goal of these competitions is to hoover data on early stage companies and on-sell to VCs and others.
- gnicholas 7y agoInteresting hypothesis, and quite possibly true. As long as they're not charging startups, actually giving exposure to the finalists, and not misrepresenting the program or odds of being selected, I don't really have a problem with it. Is there a conflict of interest or something else I'm missing?