5 ms·
>99% of climatologist agree on the science This is not a compelling argument for a skeptic. >99% of all numerologists agree on the science You need to highli
by kortilla 7y ago
>99% of climatologist agree on the science
This is not a compelling argument for a skeptic.
>99% of all numerologists agree on the science
You need to highlight the backing by the rest of the scientific community to give confidence that it’s a real science.
- beat 7y agoWhen 99% of the experts in the field agree, and that's not a compelling argument to a layman with no expertise, "skeptic" is not a word I'd use to describe that layman.
- sachdevap 7y agoVery much this. Ugh, so much ignorance in the name of "skepticism" in this thread!
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- kortilla 7y agoDid you take more than two seconds to think that through? If that was a compelling argument, everyone would believe in numerology because everyone that calls themselves a numerologist agrees that numerology is real. Same for psychics, priests, and on and on.
- SketchySeaBeast 7y agoDoesn't that then stand that you need to qualify the backing of the rest of the scientific community, then qualify the backing of those backing the backing, then qualify the backing of those who are doing the back of the backing of the backing? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, but the burden of proof decreases as the claims become less extraordinary. I'd suggest "a whole line of science which until this point hasn't been controversial" can probably be trusted, and that immediately choosing to disregard a group when it says something you don't like strikes as more reactionary than skeptical. I very much doubt you considered all of climate science a hack science until it started to butt up against your personal beliefs.
- kortilla 7y ago>Doesn't that then stand that you need to qualify the backing of the rest of the scientific community, then qualify the backing of those backing the backing, Nope. Once you’ve there is backing from fields that you already trust experts in, then you can be relatively sure that the field is following scientific methods closely, etc. >a whole line of science which until this point hasn't been controversial Any science that makes predictions on complex systems without the ability to run tightly controlled experiments is pretty controversial to many in hard sciences. To see why: see social psychology for an example of a field filled with trash. >I very much doubt you considered all of climate science a hack science until it started to butt up against your personal beliefs. I very much doubt you read my comment if you think this has anything to do with my beliefs. I was pointing out a fallacious argument from authority that holds zero weight to people who don’t believe that authority. If saying that 99% of climatologists agree was enough to settle the argument, it would be enough for 99% of police to agree that police abuse isn’t a problem.
- VikingCoder 7y agoLet's try an analogy. 99% of the sailors on a lifeboat say, "We need to paddle West, or we'll all die." Sure, you have every right to be skeptical. But don't you think we should probably paddle West? If someone starts trying to paddle East, shouldn't everyone in the boat try to stop them? Yes, the sailors may be mistaken. But given the divisions of labor we have, and our limited understanding of the world, don't you think we should follow the best advice we can get? Is there some better way you can imagine to gather the best advice?
- genericone 7y agoDuring China's cultural revolution, for the sake of taking a Great Leap Forward, whole country-sides melted their metal housewares and cookware (trying to make steel) and killed all their sparrows ( to eliminate farm pests ) because the people were misinformed, but also mostly because the people were severely disincentivized from disagreeing. Going against the party line at that time meant you and your family going to work-camps for re-education, not simply just getting canceled. You don't always want to follow the masses, the 99%. In your scenario, there's no way for the sovereign individual to go East unless he can find the ones in the 99% with the cognitive dissonance. Abandoning ship would be the metaphorical equivalent of becoming a hermit and giving up on society.
- VikingCoder 7y agoDo you really think that peer-reviewed scientists, who are the experts in their field, are on the same par as a totalitarian government, in terms of how accurately they can understand and model reality and make accurate predictions? There's no Other Earth. If Climate Change is real, then we all need to paddle in the same direction.
- genericone 7y agoClimate change is real, but what level of corrective behavior are climate alarmists willing to commit to? A man, Allan Savory, acting on what was near unanimous scientific agreement on the cause of desertification, could have remained a mere scientist raising the alarm about deserts. Thinking he knew what the solution was, and getting the approval of other scientists, he went on to kill tens of thousands of elephants. https://www.fastcompany.com/2681518/this-man-shot-40000-elephants-before-he-figured-out-that-herds-of-cows-can-save-the-planet https://www.fastcompany.com/2681518/this-man-shot-40000-elep...
- gnaritas 7y ago> This is not a compelling argument for a skeptic. A layman rejecting the opinions of 99% of the climatologist's community is not skepticism, it's ignorance. That is not what skepticism is.
- adrianN 7y agoThe skeptic can go and read the relevant papers and if they find flaws in them write their own paper. If their counterarguments are compelling they'd likely convince more than one or two percent of the climate scientists.
- yongjik 7y ago> You need to highlight the backing by the rest of the scientific community ... Would you be satisfied by 76 Nobel Laureates? http://www.mainaudeclaration.org/ http://www.mainaudeclaration.org/ > As of 1 February 2016, 76 Nobel Laureates have expressed their support of the Mainau Declaration 2015.
- kortilla 7y agoGood. Highlight that. Validation by the rest of the scientific community that a field is real science goes miles further than claiming “this religious group believes in their religion so it must be the right one”.