Late to reply, sorry. Yes there are ups and downs, but you can setup automatic deductions from paychecks straight into an HSA. I haven't done the full analysis

Late to reply, sorry. Yes there are ups and downs, but you can setup automatic deductions from paychecks straight into an HSA. I haven't done the full analysis and asked everyone at work, but if the trend continues for the next few years it's going to be really hard for a high deductible HSA plan to not come out ahead. Whether or not we eat the extra cost to keep the convenience will be a decision to be made then. My comment was only to serve as counterpoint that companies aren't all looking at an HSA because they want to screw people over. Many are looking at an HSA based health plan because they are increasingly becoming more attractive as benefits shrink while becoming more expensive. Again, I am friends with my coworkers, my family is on the same health plan, and I have everyone's best interest in mind, and I wouldn't approach the decision lightly. Obviously there are shitty people out there managing employer plans, I don't speak for them!