3 ms·
> The sudden thawing of Arctic permafrost is of great concern to scientists, who say that the methane and carbon dioxide gas that the process releases is accele
by pier25 7y ago
> The sudden thawing of Arctic permafrost is of great concern to scientists, who say that the methane and carbon dioxide gas that the process releases is accelerating global warming.
This type of language really bothers me. That methane and other feedbacks are accelerating global warming are proven facts.
- mikestew 7y agoI don't understand how the quoted statement and yours differ. The scientists say thawing permafrost accelerates warming, and you say that's a fact. Can you be more specific for the caffeine-deprived?
- deleted 7y ago[deleted]
- Diederich 7y ago> This type of language really bothers me. Why? It seems like the statement agrees with yours: "The sudden thawing of Arctic permafrost is of great concern to scientists, who say that the methane and carbon dioxide gas that the process releases is accelerating global warming."
- umvi 7y agoGP doesn't want the statement to read: "scientists believe X", he wants it to read: "X is a fact that is not up for debate" reply
- pier25 7y agoYes, that's what I would expect from Nature. Maybe not from the NY Times.
- pier25 7y agoBy stating that "someone else says X" it doesn't imply that X is a fact only that maybe it is. The statement is not wrong, it just bothers me that Nature of all mediums would do that on this particular topic. It's really mindblowing that feedbacks aren't more present in conversations about climate change considering these are probably the most dangerous and IMO terrifying aspects. Even the IPCC has been evading the subject: > Mario Molina, who shared the Nobel prize in chemistry in 1995 for his work on depletion of the ozone layer, said: “The IPCC report demonstrates that it is still possible to keep the climate relatively safe, provided we muster an unprecedented level of cooperation, extraordinary speed and heroic scale of action. But even with its description of the increasing impacts that lie ahead, the IPCC understates a key risk: that self-reinforcing feedback loops could push the climate system into chaos before we have time to tame our energy system, and the other sources of climate pollution.” https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/09/tipping-points-could-exacerbate-climate-crisis-scientists-fear https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2018/oct/09/tipping-...
- lucb1e 7y agoIs that what it signals? As someone who isn't a native speaker but believes themselves close to one, I don't read it that way. I understand that "X says that Y are Z" is less strong a statement than "Y are Z", but with something as complex as this, it's hard to state it as fact without coming across as if it is your own research or conclusion. I can write 2+2=4 without that, but I can hardly write that donald duck running a leading economy is bad for the whole planet without it seeming like an opinion to those who either looked at different examples as I did or those who are not completely convinced it is a fact. (That was exaggerated obviously, but you get the picture: if I had written the donald duck statement like "scientists say that $complexSystemThatFew(IfAnyone)CanTrulyProve", it seems more likely to be true than without it, regardless of whether it truly is a fact.)
- pier25 7y ago> Is that what it signals? As someone who isn't a native speaker but believes themselves close to one, I don't read it that way. Maybe you are right. I read it that way but I'm not a native speaker either.
- sp332 7y agoGood journalists don't make you take their word for something. Citing the source of information is good practice. Edit: I guess it would have helped if they said which scientists.
- pier25 7y agoThis is very relative. Accepted facts are not cited every time they are cited in an article. I would understand a mainstream journal use that type of language, but not a scientific one.
- VikingCoder 7y agoTo the best of our current understanding, they are accepted by the scientific community. Do you need to see that proviso expressed every single time?
- pier25 7y ago> they are accepted by the scientific community That's precisely my point. Saying "scientists say X" does not transmit that X is accepted by the scientific community. > Do you need to see that proviso expressed every single time? I do since I consider climate change a serious and urgent matter.