3 ms·
Lost in the announcement is the fact that they're opening this for global research because... they don't really have anything queued up yet. High-aperture radi
by ajross 7y ago
Lost in the announcement is the fact that they're opening this for global research because... they don't really have anything queued up yet. High-aperture radio astronomy doesn't really have a hook right now.
Arecibo was built half a century ago now, and ever since has remained (by far) the most sensitive radio telescope available. Yet... it hasn't found much that we didn't already know about. FAST seems likely to sit in the same realm: it'll be able to see known phenomenon farther away, but that's about it.
We have plenty of radio sensitivity right now, what we need is broader coverage to pick up transient things like FRB's, and (as always) longer baselines for VLBI work (e.g. the Event Horizon "Telescope"), both of which which mean more dishes, not one giant dish.
- tremulens 7y agoIs there anything preventing them from tuning up FAST so it's as or even more sensitive than Arecibo? Like, is it just a matter of better sensors or dish design? Maybe we don't need it, but cleaner data would be nice at least.
- ajross 7y agoFAST will surely be better than Arecibo, absent some kind of terrible technical glitch. The point was more that, post-Arecibo (and again we're talking the 1970's here) there has been no rush to build more Arecibo-style dishes, because the perceived scientific benefit is low.
- tremulens 7y agoI see. Curious they just spent a big wad of cash on it, though I suppose they've been doing lots of construction work with marginal utility.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoIt is more sensitive than arecibo already.
- SiempreViernes 7y agoI think this is a bit unfair: better point sensitivity has obvious scientific value, it just isn’t the most cost effective radio project if you have expertise in building arrays already. And those extragalactic pulsar studies they hope to do sound pretty nice.